“托宾悖论“的谜底与修正——信用货币经济增长模型中的资本集中和经济加速功能

“托宾悖论“的谜底与修正——信用货币经济增长模型中的资本集中和经济加速功能 “托宾悖论“的谜底与修正——信用货币经 济增长模型中的资本集中和经济加速功能 1???I3?9 2004??8?o ???????????????? JournalofNanji?DAuditUniversity Vol.1?aNo.3 Aug.?a2004 )g?????c??)(???g???f???? ???S?E?1?????????[???:???!?I???:?????????9???? ?????? (?????????????????????a????????21O029) [????QU???????????????????E?1?????????[???S?)?????E?1?????????}?r?a?8?????????????S?E?1?S?U?? ?????????[???f???~?????+???-?????????a?????E?1???????????+?l?T???)??????Q3???f?a?u?????4?u???????? ???????(?????????????[??Q3?t?4???k?a?????????[?????????4???M?I?????+???????E?1?f???S?????v?n?????? ?????f???????S??Q1???S?E?1???)???E?1???M?I?S??Q3?t?4???????[?????????????????????????????.Q3 Qt???Y??QU????????;?E?1?????????[??;???S?E?1?????????[?? [?:???8????QUF82oQt???Y?J???1QUA[?????v??QU1672??8750(2004)03??0028??05 ???????l????????????????????(JA??[ESTQt)~ BIN)???E?1?????????[?????k?a?f?????????????[?? ?????a?*???E?1?????:?????v?k???????!?????????? ?N???????????:?????????!?a???????E?1?????????: ???????????N???????????:??????????Q3?*?????~ ?????f???????]???f???????????a?}????????)g???? ????)(Q3?I?????k:????)g????????)(???????+?????? ?u?k?8)g?E?1????)(?f)g???S?E?1????)(Q1)g?????)???E ?1????)(?f)g???S?E?1????)(?????B?a???u?0?4??)g???S ?E?1)(?S?????????:?}???u???????????9???????a?S ???????r???S??)g???????8??)(?a?????Q??)g?S?r????)( ?????k?????????a??)g???t????????)(?????k?E?1???? ?2???a???a?????????~???]???~??????Q3?????r?a)g?? ??????)(?l???+???S?E?1?????????[???:??????Q3 1.???????????~?????+???-?????N ?E?1???????????~?????+???-??: Q1??Y+??Q?? ??Q1)g????????)(?????I???? ???????E?1?????????[???????????????n: ?????N?????a???????E?1???????????????+?? ?-?????????????a?????u?????????f?E?1?k?????? ?9???k?~?????+???-???a?????u???f???????E?1?+ ???????????E?1????????Q3 2.???????????~?????+???-?????N ?U?????S?E?1???m???????????????????~???? ?+???-???[??: (1)???S?E?1???m?v???S?E?1???????E?????? ???? *???v???aQ1??)s????Q1Q3?aQ3:Q1Q1?aQ1 ???S?E?1???m?????k??????????(K?aL)?v???????J?UQ1)(??)y.)g??J??~?//?JP)s)()g-- ??)y~F??~ [?-?{???9QU2004??03??30 Qj???4????QU??????(1949??)?a?=?a???????????a?l???E?????????????a???????????? ?????????????a???_???a?:???v?????????V?]???8?? Qr?????t??Qn???????????a?:???????????????V????Q3?_???????????8???f?????t??Q 3 28?? sy+??ny???(y= y[5??(1??5)?(] ???? ???? ???? ???] ??F--?E?????????C ?]?a?a1?aQ1.?a syL)s??(;???9)??Ql (2)?U????????????n?????S?E?1???m???? ?????2?????}???????????a?????/?????2???a?? ???S?E?1???m??????/?]???????S?E?1????M/?]?a?S?? ???L?????????????????n?a??????????n(???????? ????)?????-????????dF(k?aL)/dt/F(K?aL)?a ?y?u: ?*??y=??(k)?r?N???M?k ??=f(k)[:??(1??5)??QU ?M??5=1???????????a???a?u??=?F?a?y: QaQ1??(1??:)?(]??(k)=nk ??_Q1??(Q1?a:?a??Q1Y??t (3)???????????~?????+???-???[?? YQ3=Y+??ny=Y(1+?() ?r?N?*?+???????E?1?????????????[??Q3 5.???????? ???????E?1?????????[???f???????????????[ ???????+?~???????????i?-???/???????????n?NQ3 ???????????????[???k: 3.???????E?1???????????[??(???????????? ?~?????+???-???[???6???a????:??????) (1)?E?1?????:???+???-?????_??????SYD sYD=sy(1+??) (2)?E?1?????:???9???v?k???!???????? ??Sn ?????????a?*???????????E?1?????????????V ?????v???+???-???a?1?u?a?S???t?????????:?a?E?1 ?l???+???C???????????????????????????????a?+ ?>?V?_???V???????????M?S?a???????v?k???!?a?? ???a?????E?1???????+???-?????_???????:?????? ???????E?1?a???n?????????????v?k???!?a???????? ?????????k: sD??syn???)??syn??Q1Y??L =SY+??ny???(Y ?*??Q3<??<)s;???a(Q1?{:??Q1Y)<0?a?}?? ?????????????????????E???E?1?????:?????????? ???a??:sy>SDQ3 ?>?-?a???????+???????????????!?E???E?1?? ???????!?a?l???a???????????u?6?~????:???+???? ???E?1?+?J?)?????????E?1?a???????k?????????V ????;???+???????E?1?l???u???S?E?1?????????a?? ?!?I???:Q1???????-?v???????)?????S???9????Q3 4.?????????????+???-??y?????????????? Sd?[??(?8?r???E?1???????+???-???_?????N???? ???????????N?6???0???????_????L) sf(k)=nk ?S?????[???:?a(1??Q1)?u>0?a?C[5??(1??Q1)?uQU <Q1?a?E?1?????:???????????????N???????????:?? ?????????????a??: [Q1??(1??:)?(??f(k)<sf(k) ???a?a?E?1???????????????????i?-???N???? ???????:???????????????i?-???a?S???N???k?*?+: {[5??(1??5)?(QUf(k)=?j}<{sf(k)=?F} ???*?+?}?d??)g????????)(Q3???B???+:???????a ???E?1?U???????f?a?????????????????+???-???a?u ?????????[???????a?E?1?????????i?-???????E???? ??????;?????????a?M???E?1?????????[?????????a?E ?1?????????i?-?????N???????????????i?-??Q3 ??Q1??)g????????)(?????? )g????????)(???????f?a???????>?-?????????? ?]???????????????a?????a?k?????V???9)g????????)( ????V?]???????+:???????k?????????E?1???-?? ?j???~?????+???-???a???+?????*?E?1???j???-?? ?l???+?E?1?;???v???????1?????????u?:???????? ?V?????a???l?+???????????????????????!?a???a?E ?1?+?????;???:?l?????v?k?????????!?????d?? ???a???+?>?V?;?????????a???a?E?1?????l???l???? ?????i?-???a???a???i???i?-??Q3???=?a?u???????? ???*???E?1?????????N???v?k?!?I?????????????? ???E?1?????????[??Q3???:?????l?????4?u???? ?rQ1?U????????????????Q3 ?????a?????r???????????E?1??????Q3?????? ??29?? :?E?1???????l?? ???????a???????M?E?1?+?S???M?E?1???l??Q3?}???a ?~?????+???-???4???u?~???8:???9?????}???j?? ?-??Q1?????????C?E?1????Q1?????????C?E?1?????} ???????l??Q3???a?????????C?E?1?????????V???? ?M???v?k???V?????!?????i?-???a???????????C?E ?1?????????????!?????????S?E???????????C?E?1 ???????9???S(??)g????????)()???a?E?1?????????? ?E????????????????;???????????C?E?1???????? ?????!?????????S?N???????????C?E?1???????9?? ?S???a?*?V???j)g????????)(Q3 ?U???????????????y?M?????T?????????8???? ???r???E?1???M???????????????????a???????k?a?E ?1???M???f???????M?????k?B?+?a?E?1???M?????? ?D?+?1?u???????5???????????-???v???????k?V?j ?I?a?6?4?a???i???vQ3???????a?1?u???C?E?1?????? ?k?V?j?I?k?????!?I???-?????f???C?E?1???????- ??????????????Q3???=?a???C???+???-?????????i ?-??(y)???r???????l???E?1???????C???D?a???? ?r?????????C?E?1???????r?????C?T??Q3?*???? ???a?U?????????????????l???+???????r?????C?E ?1???????l?????M???????????k?1?u?E?1???k?V?j ?I(?T??)?v?1?u?E?1?????????-????Q3?????f???? ?????a???+???k???+???-???+?*???????i?-?????r ???????????C?E?1???????jQ3?????f???????k?B?+ ?????????????C?E?1????????????????:??????)g?E ?1)(?+???k?E?1???E?1?a???V?+???k?!?????E?1;???? ?rQ1?U???????????????y??)g?E?1)(?y?+???k???M???? ?E?1?????k?l?????E?1???????u?k?V?j?I???E?1Q3 ???k???????M?E?1?f???M???????=?a?+???M?????g?? ???????a?????k?????a?E?1???S?????????:???7???SQ3 ???u?a???????????C?E?1?????????????9???! ???2????????????????????Q3???????k?E?1?+?9?? ?????:?????~?9?????)Q3?f???????????????[???? ???a???????[???????????~?????????C?E?1??Q3?? ???N?k: ?????a???????k?a???????M)s?k:Q3=f(k?am)?? ?j?a???=?a???????????M???Q???E?D???????+:c)y= ??(k?a?j??(?>))s??Q3?a???*?+?}?d)g????????)(?a?? ???L?????????????????+:u=n?????a???*???M???? ???L???????????????sQ3?????N????:n+??=0?a?? ?a?E?1???????????+:u??0?a?????s???E?1?????{ ???+???E?1?????????1?l??Q3 ?*?r???????????a?????rQ1?U???????????????? ?????????E?1?????????[?????????????+?S?E?1?? ???????????r?a?a?S?[?????E?S???????r???~?u?k ?B?a?????????????C?E?1???????????+???-???????? ???????????????8?a?????rQ1?U?????????????????? ?????Q?n?Q??)g????????)(?+?E?1???????????????? ???a???+?????????}?????????????C?E?1?????+?~?? ???+???-???????????????????????E?1????)g???? ??)(???????a???k???????????????l?+???C?E?1???? ?I???a?+?E?1?????MQ1?l?????9??????Q3?????k?i?? ?????????;?E?1?????????????S????????????????Q3 ?uQ1?E?1?f???S???????v?f???????? Y??F?????a?3 ???????????a?t?4???????~????:?E?1?+?????? ?????????-??????E?1?????}???j???~?????+???- ???????????k?????l?????v?k???!????k?~?????+ ???-???????????E?1???????f?????????+??????S ?V?E?????v?????r???????n?a???????i?????C?E?1 ???m???????????+?!?????+?!?I?)g????????)(?+?? ???E?????????+???-????????????????S?????[?? ?????f???????4???????:???u???j?v??????????Q3 ?8???????????u???n????: ?I???a?????????????????N???~?????+???-?? ???E?1???N???~?????+???-??Q3???4?+???i?-???? ?9??Q1?.?)?a?f?4?+???i?-?????E?1????;???4?+?? ???!???v?????;???a?a?f?4?+?;???!???v?E?1?!??; ???4?+?????!?I?a?a?f?4?+?;???!?IQ3???????a???? ?????u?k?8?!??Q1?!?IQ1?E?1?????S?l?a?????????? ?????n?????v?????I?S???BQ3 ?I???a???????????E?1???v?k?!?I???????f?E ?1???v?k?!???????????;????????Q3?E?1?-?????? ???????v?k?!?I???????+???m?T???a???????v?k?? ?!???????i?-?????9?????.?)???n?a?a?E?1???v?k ?0???!?????????y?l?m?V?=?a?E?V????????Q1?8??Q1 ???M???nQ3?E?1???v?k?!???+?;?????N?????v???l ?+?!?I???N?????vQ3 ?I?u?a?????????????I?E?1?????S?E?1???E?S 30?? (?v?4 ????????)???k?B?a???l?????n?Q?S?!?I?_???9???? ???n???J???S?????????v?k?!?I???????M??Q3 ?I???a?????????V?)???????????????=???S?? )g?S?r????)(?f)g???t????????)(?8???????a???u?S?? ?????D???n???????E?1?????S?E?1?S?l?a?????:?? ??????????????????Q3???????E?1?????????[???+ ?????????????????[?????????????a?v?4?+?*???? )g?S?r????)(?i??????)g???t????????)(??????????Q3 ?????a?????S?}?d?????????????[???????}?r?a?8?? ???E?1???)?a???t???k???+?????i?-???????i?a???a ?????????E?1???????????[???????????N?????S?? ???????[?????????????????]????)g????)(Q3?????? ???r???a???+??)g?S?r????)(?f)g???t????????)(???? ?_?????????y???8???a???j???l?o?_????????Q3?? ???r?a)g?S?r????)(?f)g???t????????)(???+?????E?1 ???????[???a?6?4???k?B???S???f?4?[???:?f???? ???~?????E?1)t???t?????????k)g??????)(?a?I?S ?r???+)g????)(?a?a?????E?1?????????[???????? ???~?2?*??????)g???t????????)(????.?????E?1 ?????????~?*???????????8????)g??????)(???I?S?2 ??Q3?????a?????????????????????????[?????k?? ???????????[???a?a?????????????????[?????k?E ?1?????????[???+???u???8???a???C?r?a?6?4???+?E ?1???????????[???a???l??????????????)g????)(?? ?)???E?1??)g???S???i?-??)(?:?????????a?-?f???? ???Q?[???:??????Q3?}???a?????N???l?Q?E?1???? ??)g???S?v)(??)g???????)?9???v)(?}???9?????????: ?f???????9?????a?n?l?Q???S?E?1?l???+???????? ???a?????a?????u?????????????????)?????????? ?????S????Q3?}???a???????-?+?~?E?1?v?9???4Q3 ???????S?E?1?????????[???v?????k???????????? ?[?????k?o?3????Q3 )g????????)(???j???????~?????+?a?)???????? ????????)g?S?r????)(?f)g???t????????)(???????u?? ?E?k??(?t?4???u?d?????f)?a????)g???t????????)( ?:??)g??????)(?f)g?S?r????)(?:???E?1???????????? ?????a???8???k?E?1??)g??????)(????)g?S?r?????N)( ??)g??????)(?a???a??)g?S?r????)(???????????????? ?[???a?a??)g???t????????)(?????E?1?????????[???a ??)g??????)(???????????v?9???)?a??????)g????)(?a?D ??)g???t????????)(?V???????~)g??????)(?a???t?S)g?? ?t????????)(????)g?S?r????)(????????????)g???? ??)(??????Q1?E?SQ1?????f????????Q3 ?6?????J?????+?a)g????????)(???u?2???Q)g???t ????????)(?f???????????????????[???????}???? ?????6?4?????????S?????a???a?~?????f?U?????? ?????????[?????E?1???)?+?k??Q1????Q1?????V?? )g???t????????)(???????????}??????Q1???-?V???. ?)????????????Q3 ?I???a???????????????????????i?-???f?E?1 ???????????~?????+???-????????????????Q3?S?? ???????+???-???[???:?a???????+?????Q?S???u?? ?i?-?????}?r?????????E?1???8?????j?????~???? ?+???-??Q3???????????????l?????)???????????? ??Q3???k?a?S?????????????C???n?:?a???}?E?1???> ?f???V???????e???9?????3?k???n?????????k???i ?-???a???:???V?????!????Q1???>?E?1????Q1?-???f ???!?????9???????S???9?V?l?????i?-???a???i?- ???????????n?l?+???9???????n?a?a?+?!?I?l???Q ???:?????9?????????????nQ3???~???n???S?r?+?? ?S?E?1?v?4???????)?l?????7???S?????nQ3?}???a ?~?????+?????i?-???[???:?????i?-???f?????E?1 ???????????????l?+???????_?m?????????????a?a ??31 (??1)?? ???Q???kQ3 y??1{???{?1???B?8?1 ?a!----??????/)s}//}/??=sj(y?a??nyj 1/1/???]???? ?? 11!1.!Q3Q3 - k* ?+???k???????????????9??????Q3?????a???i?-?? ?????????n?V???Q???????8?????9???8?f???i?-?? ???k?????i???????????????a?????i?-???0?????/ ?????????a???????8?????9?????8?V????????????; ???????0?????????a???????8?????9?????8?????V ?U???????????9???n??Q3?>?-?a???????E?1?????? ???[?????n?Q?E?1?????????i?-?????????????a???u ?n?Q?E?1???????????????n?????????a?S???????[?? ?:?a?E?1???????????????~?????+???-?????a?????? ?i?-???a?????9?*???E?1???)???????a?U?????????i ?-?????n???a?>?-?a?????[?????-?????S???????E?1 ???????????n?????????a???+?????S?E?1?????????? ?9??????????????????Q3???-?a?l?????S?E?1?????? ?????V???????????n?V???????????????!???j?I?a?? ?a?????????????????a???????+?????????:???????a ?l?+???S?E?1?????????[????????Q3 ?????a?????M?)?v???????????????????[??? ?k???????????[?????S???????????????????)?~?? ???+???-?????_???????a?i?????S???i?-???f?E?1 ???????k?????????????)?~?????+???-???[?????? ?????~?????+???-???[?????n: ??1???S?E?1???????????[???? ??=F[Y?ad(M/?])/d?? ?U?????S?E?1???m?????C????????????n?a?y: YQ3=F(Y?a?Cny) ???S???????+???-???????N?a?r?N?y?k ??=f(y?a?(y) ?~?????+???-?????????k: SD=SYIQU??sF(Y?a??Y) ???????+???-?????????k: ??=sf(y?a?(y) ?*???????????i?-???????j?????k: ??=?F ?}???a?S???S?????????[???:?a???i?-???????? ?????k: sf(y?a??y)=?j ?????N?????a?*???~?????+???-?????S?????? ???N?a?U???E?1?????f???????-??Q1?????????????? ?k?????N?a???k???????????????u???????9 ???8Q3???S?E?1?????m?????+?????????9?????a?? ?????k?f???????????????[???????I?????? ?a?a?f?????[?????l?a???0?S??:???u???????????E ?1?????????????????????????a?a?+???????????? ?????9???)?????????????????????????????????? ???a?k?2???S?E?1???????????S?l?S???E?1?+?l?+ ???V????Q1???M???????9???!???a?a?S???????????? ???:?????????9????Q3???u???=?a?????????E?1?? ???k????????Q1?k?????E?1?????u???????9?E???? ????????????????Q3?????=???????k?-?????????? ???????????8Q1???9?????8Q1???>?E?1?.?)?????f?? ?i?-????????Q1?????????????a???Q???-????????Q1 ???????9Q1?????????/?????k?-Q1????Q3 ???S?E?1?????????[?????{??????: ?I???a?????~?????+???-???a?????????????? ???a?????9???????9?????)?????S?a???????????? ?-???v?a?????2?????????C?E?1?1?u???CQ1???????? ??nQ3??y???j?????????????f?????S???i?-???}?? ???????????S?E?1????Q3 ?I???a???S?E?1?????n?????????????n?+???? ?????:?!?I?????9?????????????????nQ3?}???a?? ???E?1?{?????2???????????+???S?E?1?????:?!?I ???????????S?E?1???????????????9????Q3 ?I?u?a???????????E?1?????{???+???S?E?1?{ ??Q3?????E?1???????????)?l???u?E?1?.?)???a?? ?u???S?.?)?????9??Q3????????(?n???I61??) .32 (4)???????????1?? ???E?a??????????????Q3 ???-?a?????????a?S???8?????l?????j???????) ???;???????????l???j?k?E???V?????????E???l?? ????(?????k)g?(?L???V)()?????a?????????V?????? ???C???????o???C?????8?????o???????????????? ?S???i????????Q3?*?????????6???????????F???? ?????????}???k?u????????Q3?<???????a?Q?????k ???a???V?????-?S?V???????????????8?a???????? ???a?*?????f?????????*???6?????????F?????u?? ?????????N??Q3 8.?M??)g???????????????????}?f?????F?Q?? ???M???????V?F??)(?6?????????F ?????????j?f?????????????F?f?????V?Q???? ????????????Q3?????????V?Q?????m???????????? ?}???????>?V?F??Q3?????????V???????????S???a ???????>?V?a???????????????V?Q??Q3?S???????E ?????:?a???m????????:(1)???????????????yQ3?? ?u???????????????y???N???}???????????FQ3???+ ?6???????????+?5???????F?????M?I?????a?+???? ???????V?????????mQ3(2)???1????Q1????Q1?????? ???y?????9???????9Q3???+???????????????V?? ??Q1???V?Q???????u?????a?+???????v??????????Q3 ???r?????????I???????????v???6?????????F ???????N???:?4??????:?????????+???????????F ?????I?????a?+?6???????F?????8??????Q3?????? ???????v???????6?????????F???u?????E?N??Q3 Qt???2???YQU [1QU???{???a??.?????t??????[M].?r??:?r???;???E???? ???>?a2002. [2]?;?{???????V???o?2???????V??????.????[MQU.?e??: ?:???;?{?????????>?a2002. [3]???S?a?N???B?a???i???a????.?????8??????[MQU.?:???? ?V?????>?a1990. [4QU??????.????????Q1???????y?f?????F????????[J].?; ?V?o?r?a2002?a(4). [5Ql???l?a??????.???i???O?r?????-?????(?2[J].?:???? ???a2004?a(3). [?F???v??:????] ?o?????o?????a?o??11?o???N?o???????a???o??11?o????????.???????o??11?o?????a? o????.?o???????a???o????.??????.?????o?a???????o???o?????o??11?o???????o????1 ?????o?a?*?o???????????????????a?????N?o???o?a??.?o?????o???:?4???f?o?????o?? ???o???o???????????o?????o??11?o?? (?r???I32??)?????S?!???????????[Q1?????????) ?????2???????o???-Q3 ?I???a???S?E?1?????+????????Q3?????2?????S ?E?1???E?1?{???I?S?r?+?????????{??Q3?????E?1 ?{?????????4?????~?????????????????S?E?1???? ??Q3???S?E?1???????l?????4?????????????????= ?E?1?????a?????4???E?1?3?kQ1?!?I?3?kQ1?????3?k?? ?????????J???S?E?1???????9???3?k?r???E?1????Q3 ?I???a???????-?????I?2???+?E?1Q1????Q1?T?? ?????SQ3?S?E?1???S?????v???????n?a?????2???? ?????S???k????Q3???j???~???]?l?m??????????Q3 ?}???????E?1?????{???+?~?????a?l??????Q3???- ?????????n???S?r?+???-?!???S?>?V???9?????n?0 ?~?-?????????????????????nQ3???????????2???? ?f?>?V???9???????????v????????Q3 ????:???1?8???????????>?a1996. [2]???T.?????r.???????>?????????????????[???:???E?1 [?o.???T.?????r.?E?1???????????u[C].?????5??:?? ??.?*?5?f?3???????>?a1978. [3QU?U?????a????????.?E?1?S?????????[???:?????S[A]. ?U????.?E?1???????t??[C].????????:???U?f?????? ?>?a1972. [4]?;??.?????8????????????[M].???????7:???7?E???? ???>?a2000. [5]?????K.?????????8??[MQU.?e??:?:?????????? ?>?a2000. [6]?????j?a???????a??????.?????E?1??????[M].?e??:?: ???????????>?a2Q3Q32. [7]?????7?a???N???a??????.?????E?1?????8??[M].?r??: ?l???E???????>?a200o. Qt???2???YQUQa?F???v??:?????f] [1]????.???1?_???[??[AQl.????.????????????[C].???? ??61??