There is growing concern about theeffects of man-made noise on marinelife. In particular, marine mammals
that use sound to communicate, navigate,
and detect predators and prey may try to
avoid loud sound sources up to tens of kilo-
metres away1. Here, in a study conducted in
cooperation with the US Navy2, we show
that the singing behaviour of male hump-
back whales was altered when they were
exposed to LFA (low-frequency active)
sonar. As the song of these whales is associ-
ated with reproduction3, widespread alter-
ation of their singing behaviour might
affect demographic parameters, or it could
represent a strategy to compensate for
interference from the sonar.
During the breeding season male hump-
back whales sing long, complex songs that
are thought to be sexual displays3. Songs
consist of a series of themes, progressing in
a predictable order, that may repeat for sev-
eral hours4. We used a small observation
vessel to find singing humpbacks and con-
duct focal sampling5, recording behaviour
before, during and after playback. (Strictly
speaking, we have evaluated the additional
impact that LFA sounds have on a singing
whale that is already being followed.)
We recorded the vocal behaviour of each
focal singer continuously for several hours
using a towed, calibrated hydrophone
array6. When the whale was at the surface,
observers sampled visible behaviour. Pho-
tographs of fluke and dorsal fin features
confirmed the whale’s identity throughout
each follow7. At least two songs were
recorded before the observation vessel
requested the US Navy R/V Cory Chouest to
transmit ten (in one case four) 42-s LFA
signals at 6-min intervals. The sonar was
broadcast at less than full strength, and no
focal singer was exposed to a signal louder
than 150 dB (with respect to 1 mPa).
Sixteen singers were followed during 18
playbacks. In nine follows, the whale sang
continuously throughout the playback; in
four the singer stopped when he joined
other whales (typical of normal social inter-
action); and in five the singer stopped, pre-
sumably in response to the playback. We
recorded at least one complete song in all
conditions from six individuals, and pooled
the songs of each of the two individuals that
were subjects in two experiments. For these
six whales, we measured the duration and
theme structure of song spectrograms,
comparing song duration in the three con-
ditions using analysis of variance8.
On average, humpback whales’ songs
were 29% longer during LFA playbacks
(Fig. 1) — a particularly strong result, given
the low power of the test and small sample
size9. Song duration returned to normal
after exposure, suggesting that this response
has a limited duration. There was little dif-
ference in the likelihood of an aberrant
theme transition across exposure condi-
tions (x243.273, P40.195), indicating that
long songs resulted from longer themes
within a normal song structure. Across the
six singers, maximum received level of the
sonar at the whale did not correlate posi-
tively with either the increase in mean song
duration from pre-exposure to exposure
condition (r410.90) or with the subse-
quent decrease from exposure to post-expo-
sure condition (r410.63).
We suggest that humpbacks sang longer
songs during LFA sonar transmissions to
compensate for acoustic interference. Our
study shows that it is possible to measure
the behavioural responses of individual
whales in controlled experiments at sea.
Patrick J. O. Miller*, Nicoletta Biassoni*,
Amy Samuels*†, Peter L. Tyack*
*Biology Department, Woods Hole Oceanographic
Institution, Woods Hole, Massachusetts 02543, USA
†Daniel F. and Ada L. Rice Conservation Biology
and Research Center, Chicago Zoological Society,
Brookfield, Illinois 60513, USA
1. Richardson, W. J., Greene, C. R. Jr, Malme, C. I. & Thomson,
D. H. Marine Mammals and Noise (Academic, San Diego, 1995).
2. Waters, M. A. US Federal Register 61, 37452–37453 (1996).
3. Tyack, P. L. Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol. 8, 105–116 (1981).
4. Payne, R. & McVay, S. Science 173, 585–597 (1971).
5. Altmann, J. Behaviour 49, 227–267 (1974).
6. Miller, P. J. & Tyack, P. L. Deep-Sea Res. II 45, 1389–1405 (1998).
7. Katona, S. et al. in The Behavior of Marine Mammals (eds Winn,
H. E. & Olla, B. L.) 33–44 (Plenum, New York, 1979).
8. Zar, J. H. Biostatistical Analysis (Prentice-Hall, Englewood
Cliffs, NJ, 1984).
9. Lehmann, E. L. Ann. Math. Stat. 29, 1167–1176 (1958).
brief communications
NATURE | VOL 405 | 22 JUNE 2000 | www.nature.com 903
Whale songs lengthen in response to sonar
Male humpbacks modify their sexual displays when exposed to man-made noise.
Pre- During Post-
0
5
10
15
20
Exposure condition
S
on
g
d
ur
at
io
n
(m
in
)
Figure 1 Duration of songs (5s.e.m.) produced by humpbacks
before, during and after exposure to LFA sonar transmissions
(bold, filled diamonds, mean of all six singers; other symbols, indi-
vidual singers). The maximum received level of the sonar at the
whale ranged from 130 to 150 dB re 1 mPa. Songs were grouped
in the exposure condition if a sonar transmission occurred at any
point during the song. The average number of songs per singer in
the pre-exposure, exposure and post-exposure conditions was
3.2, 4.7 and 3.8, respectively. Differences were assessed using a
mixed-model analysis of variance treating exposure condition as a
fixed factor, whale identity as a random factor, and each song
duration as an independent observation. The effect of exposure
condition on song duration was statistically significant at
P40.047 (F2,1044.200, power40.50, n46).
Nutrition
Antioxidant activity
of fresh apples
Vitamin C is used as a dietary supple-ment because of its antioxidant activi-ty, although a high dose (500 mg) may
act as a pro-oxidant in the body1,2. Here we
show that 100 g of fresh apples has an anti-
oxidant activity equivalent to 1,500 mg of
vitamin C, and that whole-apple extracts
inhibit the growth of colon- and liver-
cancer cells in vitro in a dose-dependent
manner. Our results indicate that natural
antioxidants from fresh fruit could be more
effective than a dietary supplement.
Apples of the Red Delicious variety were
extracted using 80% acetone and their con-
tent of phenolics and flavonoids deter-
mined3,4: the extracts contained 290.254.2
and 219.851.8 mg phenolics, and
142.753.7 and 97.653.9 mg flavonoids
per 100 g apples with and without skin,
respectively. There are known to be more
phenolics in the skins of apples than in the
flesh, and quercetin glycosides are found
only in the skins5.
We measured the total antioxidant activ-
ity of apples by using the total oxyradical-
scavenging capacity (TOSC) assay6 and
found that apples with skin had a higher
TOSC value than apples without skin (Fig.
1a). The total antioxidant activity of 1 g
apples with skin was 83.358.9 TOSC
(mmol vitamin C equivalents) — that is, the
© 2000 Macmillan Magazines Ltd
Marian V. Eberhardt, Chang Yong Lee,
Rui Hai Liu
Department of Food Science, 108 Stocking Hall,
Cornell University, Ithaca, New York 14853-7201,
USA
e-mail: RL23@cornell.edu
1. Podmore, I. D. et al. Nature 392, 559 (1998).
2. Herbert, V. et al. J. Nutr. 126, 1213S–1220S (1996).
3. Singleton, V. L. & Rossi, J. A. Jr Am. J. Enol. Viticult. 16,
144–158 (1965).
4. Zhisen, J., Mengcheng, T. & Jianming, W. Food Chem. 64,
555–559 (1999).
5. Burda, S., Oleszek, W. & Lee, C. Y. J. Agric. Food Chem. 38,
945–948 (1990).
6. Winston, G. W., Regoli, F., Dugas, A. J., Fong, J. H. &
Blanchard, K. A. Free Rad. Biol. Med. 24, 480–493 (1998).
7. USDA Nutrient Database for Standard Reference (1998).
8. Wang, H., Cao, G. & Prior, R. L. J. Agric. Food Chem. 44,
701–705 (1998).
9. Lunec, J. J. Int. Fed. Clin. Chem. 4, 58–63 (1992).
10.Cory, A. H., Owen, T. C., Barltrop, J. A. & Cory, J. G. Cancer
Commun. 3, 207–212 (1991).
and on nutrient availability and uptake
during summer, rather than on cambial cell
division.
From tree-ring analysis across several
sites in the Siberian subarctic, Vaganov et
al.1 provide evidence that annual variability
in mean ring width is determined by the
date of the thaw through its influence on
the date of cambial initiation, as well as by
temperature during the subsequent early
growing season. Variability in annual net
ecosystem production (NEP) is also largely
determined by the timing of the thaw3,
which enables the NEP to switch immedi-
ately and rapidly from a daily loss to a daily
gain of CO2.
Our own observations on black spruce
trees at the Boreas Southern Study Area4
show that when air temperature exceeds
11 °C and the overlying snow starts to
melt, meltwater percolates down into the
soil, the temperature of the upper soil hori-
zons rises towards 0 °C, and the switch
from a small net daily loss of carbon to a
large net gain occurs over just a few days.
In boreal conifers, the availability of soil
water is a prerequisite for the recovery of
photosynthetic capacity in spring and early
summer2.
The effect of frozen soils on annual CO2
uptake by Norway spruce at 64° N is partic-
ularly dramatic because, before the thaw,
daily solar radiation is already substantial
and effectively being wasted from the per-
spective of CO2 capture
5. Thus, CO2 uptake
is synchronized and strongly stimulated by
the thaw, and afterwards, once a critical
temperature sum is reached, cambial activi-
ty and NEP increase together as the tem-
perature rises.
Such observations related to the poor
growth of trees in boreal forests have led to
the presumption that their growth is con-
strained by temperature. By contrast with
temperate and tropical forests6, boreal for-
est trees are small in relation to their age
and coniferous boreal forests have a very
low net primary production of about 2.5
tonnes of carbon ha11 yr11 (refs 7,8). To
investigate the extent to which low temper-
ature is the primary controlling variable, a
long-term nutrient-optimization and irri-
gation experiment on Norway spruce was
set up at Flakaliden (64° N) in Sweden9.
Since 1987, we have applied complete fertil-
izer daily through every growing season
either in irrigation water or as a single solid
dose at the start of the growing season. We
found that growth on the fertilized plots
(with or without irrigation) increased by a
factor of four10 (Fig. 1a), so air temperature
cannot be the major direct constraint on
tree growth.
However, temperature may be influenc-
ing tree growth indirectly through the
length of the growing season and by its
effects on decomposition of soil organic
904 NATURE | VOL 405 | 22 JUNE 2000 | www.nature.com
antioxidant value of 100 g apples is equiva-
lent to 1,500 mg of vitamin C. Given that
the average vitamin C content in fresh
apples with skin is 5.7 mg per 100 g (ref. 7)
and that the total antioxidant activity of
0.057 mg vitamin C (in 1 g of whole apples)
is only 0.32 TOSC (Fig. 1a), then almost all
of the antioxidant activity in apples must be
due to phytochemicals.
We treated a colon-cancer cell line, Caco-
2, with extracts equivalent to 0, 5, 10, 20, 30,
40 and 50 mg ml11 apples for 96 hours (the
treatment time for maximal response). Cell
proliferation was inhibited in a dose-depen-
dent manner after exposure to apple-extract
concentrations above 20 mg ml11 (Fig. 1b):
at 50 mg ml11, inhibition was 4351% and
2954.1% for apples with skin and for
apples without skin, respectively.
We also tested the effect of apple extracts
on the proliferation of another cancer-cell
line, HepG2 human liver-tumour cells. We
found that apple extracts at 50 mg ml11
inhibited the proliferation of these cells as
well, by 5750.21% and 4050.64% for
apples with and without skin, respectively
(Fig. 1c). The extracts of apple with skin
could thus significantly (t-test, P*0.031)
reduce tumour-cell proliferation compared
with extracts of apples without skin. No
cytotoxicity of the apple extracts was seen at
any of the concentrations tested (data not
shown).
We suggest that this strong inhibition of
tumour-cell proliferation in vitro could be
due to apples’ combination of phytochemi-
cals (phenolic acids and flavonoids), as
these are natural antioxidants. It has been
proposed that the consumption of whole
fruits may provide the antioxidant balance
needed to quench reactive oxygen species8
which have been implicated in tumorigen-
esis9. Phytochemicals in apples other than
ascorbic acid seem significantly to enhance
their antioxidant properties and their
capacity to inhibit the proliferation of
tumour cells in vitro.
brief communications
100
80
60
40
20
0
120
100
80
60
110
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
83.3
0.32
46.07
M
ea
n
to
ta
l a
nt
io
xi
d
an
t
ac
tiv
ity
C
el
l p
ro
lif
er
at
io
n
(%
)
C
el
l p
ro
lif
er
at
io
n
(%
)
0 10 20 30 40 50
Apple extracts (mg ml–1)
0 10 20 30 40 50
Apple extracts (mg ml–1)
a b c
Vi
ta
m
in
C
fro
m
(A
+S
)
(A
+S
)
(A
–S
)
Figure 1 Antioxidant activity of apples and their effect on tumour-cell proliferation in vitro. a, Mean total antioxidant activity expressed by
total oxyradical-scavenging capacity (TOSC; mmol vitamin C equivalents per g) assay for 1 g apple with skin (A&S), and for apple without
skin (A1S). b, Inhibition of proliferation of Caco-2 colon-tumour cells by extracts of apple with and without skin. c, Inhibition of prolifera-
tion of HepG2 liver-tumour cells. Control samples were assayed as apple extracts, but they contained only vitamin C at the same concen-
tration that exists in apples (0.057 mg g11). Cell proliferation was determined by using the MTS assay10. Blue circles, apple with skin;
yellow circles, apple without skin; orange triangles, control extracts.
Botany
Constraints to growth
of boreal forests
Understanding how the growth of treesat high latitudes in boreal forest iscontrolled is important for projec-
tions of global carbon sequestration and
timber production in relation to climate
change. Is stem growth of boreal forest trees
constrained by the length of the growing
season when stem cambial cells divide1, or
by the length of the period when resources
can be captured2? In both cases, the timing
of the thaw in the spring is critical: neither
cambial cell division nor uptake of nutri-
ents and carbon dioxide can occur while the
soil is frozen. Here we argue, on the basis of
long-term observations made in northern
Saskatchewan and Sweden, that the time
between the spring thaw and the autumn
freeze determines the amount of annual
tree growth, mainly through temperature
effects on carbon-dioxide uptake in spring
© 2000 Macmillan Magazines Ltd