657
Journal of Oleo Science
Copyright ©2013 by Japan Oil Chemists’ Society
J. Oleo Sci. 62, (9) 657-664 (2013)
Penetration effect of Ostrich Oil as a Promising
Vehicle on Transdermal Delivery of Sinomenine
Xin Liu, Teng Chen, Xuesong Liu, Yong Chen and Longhu Wang*
College of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Zhejiang University (310058, Hangzhou, China)
1 INTRODUCTION
Sinomenine(Fig. 1)is a bioactive alkaloid derived from
the Chinese medicinal plant, Sinomenium acutum, which
has been widely used to treat inflammatory and arthritic
diseases for one thousand years. However, oral administra-
tion of sinomenine is often limited on account of gastroin-
testinal adverse side effects, including nausea, diarrhea,
constipation, gastralgia, and occasionally vomiting. In addi-
tion, the oral route of drug delivery is not preferable for
patients with low oral bioavailability; also, the short elimi-
nation half-life of sinomenine requires frequent dosing1).
Hence, the transdermal route could be a better alternative
route, because it bypasses first-pass metabolism, minimizes
the gastrointestinal side effects, increases patient compli-
ance, maintains a constant drug level in plasma and physi-
ological effects.
An essential prerequisite for transdermal absorption of
drugs is that the drug must be capable of passing through
the skin at a sufficiently high rate to achieve therapeutic
*Correspondence to: Longhu Wang, College of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Zhejiang University 310058, Hangzhou, China
E-mail: wang2000@zju.edu.cn
Accepted March 31, 2013 (received for review February 7, 2013)
Journal of Oleo Science ISSN 1345-8957 print / ISSN 1347-3352 online
http://www.jstage.jst.go.jp/browse/jos/ http://mc.manusriptcentral.com/jjocs
Abstract: The present study investigated the feasibility of ostrich oil utilizing as a promising vehicle for
improved skin permeation of sinomenine with reference to vaseline matrix containing different content of
chemical enhancers. The fatty acid composition of ostrich oil was analyzed by GC-MS. Penetration
enhancing potential of ostrich oil on permeation of sinomenine across rat abdominal skin in vitro was
studied using an automatic diffusion cell apparatus. The content of sinomenine percutaneous absorbed was
determined by HPLC. Various parameters viz. steady-state skin flux (Jss), permeability coefficient (kP),
cumulative amount of sinomenine (Q) and enhancement ratios (ER) were calculated from the permeation
data. Fick’s law of diffusion and Scheuplein kinetic were used to evaluate the transdermal absorbent
enhancement of ostrich oil to sinomenine. Ostrich oil showed significant penetration effect on sinomenine
compared with vaseline matrix containing different content of chemical enhancers, the density sequence as
follow: 2% Azone > ostrich oil > 1% Azone plus 1% propylene glycol > 1% Azone > 3% Azone > 1%
propylene glycol. The percutaneous endosmic rate constant (Jss) and permeability coefficient (kP) of
sinomenine in ostrich oil through rat skin were 10.01 µg/cm2/h and 0.087, respectively. Ostrich oil produced
stronger enhancement (ER = 24.31) with greater cumulative amount of drug permeated (255.53 µg/cm2) up
to 24 h and caused no skin irritation. The drug release of sinomenine was coincided with Fick’s equation. In
summary, ostrich oil containing fatty acids is proposed as a promising adjuvant for use in cosmetics and
pharmaceuticals for improved permeation of drug.
Key words: ostrich oil, sinomenine, transdermal, penetration vehicle, fatty acid
Fig. 1 The chemical structures of sinomenine.
X. Liu, T. Chen, X. Liu et al.
J. Oleo Sci. 62, (9) 657-664 (2013)
658
plasma concentrations. However, the major barrier to the
percutaneous transport of drugs across the skin is stratum
corneum(SC)2). One of the most widely used strategies to
deliver an effective dose of drug through skin is to revers-
ibly reduce the barrier function of the skin with the aid of
penetration enhancers3). Fatty acids have been shown to
interact with the stratum corneum lipids, and a number of
fatty acids have been identified as skin permeation enhanc-
ers4, 5). Ostrich oil, a natural bird fat oil containing fatty
acids, has been used for alleviating various dull pains
caused by arthritis and cervical spondylosis since ancient
times, exhibiting the remarkable curative effect on aceso-
dyne and diminishing inflammation6). Meanwhile, it has
been used as an ideal adjuvant in cosmetics and pharma-
ceuticals owing to its remarkable permeability, excellent
lubrication and emulsion properties7).
In this study, ostrich oil was investigated as the test
vehicle as it is an inexpensive and rich source of natural fat
oil. Sinomenine was selected as the model drug, and rat
abdominal skin was removed hairs and used in vitro pene-
tration experiment. Various contents of Azone, propylene
glycol(PG)and the combination of Azone and PG have
been used as reference enhancers in vaseline matrix. The
fatty acid composition of ostrich oil was analyzed by
GC-MS. The influence and mechanism of ostrich oil on the
transdermal delivery of sinomenine were also evaluated.
2 EXPERIMENTAL
2.1 Materials
Standard of sinomenine(purity>99%)was purchased
from the Chinese Authenticating Institute of Material and
Biological Products(Beijing, China). Acutum alkaloid ex-
tracts that contain 98% sinomenine(w/w)was kindly pro-
vided by Zelang Medical Technology Co., Ltd(Nanjing,
China). Ostrich oil was extracted from ostrich fat by super-
critical fluids extraction(SFE)based on previously de-
scribed procedures4). Azone, propylene glycol, stearic acid,
triethanolamine and lanolin were purchased from Aladdin
Chemistry Co., Ltd.(Shanghai, China). Methanol of HPLC
grade was obtained from Amethyst Chemicals J & K Scien-
tific Ltd. All other reagents used were of analytical grade.
Deionized water purified by a Milli-Q water-purification
system was used in all experiments.
2.2 Animals
Male Sprague-Dawley rats(8 weeks old, 200-220 g)were
supplied by Central Animal House Facility of Zhejiang Uni-
versity and kept under standard laboratory conditions in
12 hr light/dark cycle at temperature 25±2℃ and humidity
70-75%. Animals were provided with standard rodent
chow and water ad libitum.
2.3 Analytical Methodology
Samples in solubility and permeation studies were ana-
lyzed by Agilent 1200 series HPLC system(Agilent Tech-
nologies, USA)with PAD detector. HPLC analysis was per-
formed according to the method of China Pharmacopoeia
2010 edition part I. The mobile phase was methanol: 0.005
M phosphate buffered(55:45, v/v)adjusted to pH 9.0 with
triethylamine. Volume of sample injected was 20 µL. Mobile
phase was run at a flow rate 1ml/min through a reverse
phase C-18 column(250 mm×4.6 mm, 5 µm, Agilent Tech-
nologies, USA). Detection wavelength was set at 265 nm,
and the retention time of sinomenine was 6.439 min. The
calibration curve was made by standard of sinomenine for
sample analysis.
For the identification of fatty acids composition in
ostrich oil, the GC method described in a previous study
was used4). The GC-MS system consists of an Agilent
6890N GC equipped with a split-splitless injector coupled
with an Agilent 5975I MS equipped with an EI ion source
and a quadrupole array detector. In the GC assay, the
column oven temperature was programmed from 130 to
170℃ at 5℃/min, holding for 30 min, and then heated to
270℃ at 30℃/min, holding for 7 min. The temperatures of
quadrupole, ion source chamber, injector and additional
channel were 150, 230, 250 and 280℃, respectively. The
carrier gas, helium(99.99%)was adjusted to a linear veloc-
ity of 1.0 mL/min. The ionization energy was 70 eV with the
total scan mode and the MS scan interval was 40-500 amu.
2.4 Solubility Studies
Solubility study was performed according to the method
of Rahul Jain et al8). Briefly, an excess amount of sinome-
nine was added to water and PG and shaken at 37±0.5℃
for more than 48 hours until equilibration. The suspensions
were centrifuged at 8,000 rpm for 15 min. The supernatant
was then filtered through 0.45 µm membrane filters and
the concentration of drug was measured by HPLC after ap-
propriate dilution. The experiments were performed in
quadruplicate and the results were shown in Table 1.
2.5 Partition Coefficient determination
n-Octanol and water were mutually saturated for 24
hours before the experiment. Octanol/water partition coef-
ficient(Po/w,)of sinomenine was determined by shake flask
method that was based on thorough mixing of the two
phases to reach the equilibrium9, 10). Stock solutions of si-
nomenine were made in aqueous solution with pH of 2, 3,
4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 adjusted with hydrochloride solution or
sodium hydroxide solution, and then presaturated with the
analytic grade n-octanol. Ten milliliters of stock solutions
were merged with 10 ml of n-octanol phase presaturated
with water, and the phases of the solvent system were mu-
tually saturated by shaking for 48 h on a mechanical shaker
at the temperature of 25±0.5. After centrifugation at 6,000
Penetration effect of Ostrich Oil as a Promising Vehicle on Transdermal Delivery of Sinomenine
J. Oleo Sci. 62, (9) 657-664 (2013)
659
rpm for 15 min, sinomenine concentrations in each phase
were determined by HPLC method. Three independent
measurements were conducted with all solutions. Apparent
partition coefficient P was calculated according to the lit-
erature11).
2.6 Preparation of formulations
The compositions of blank control formulation were
vaseline as vehicle and sinomenine(5 mg/g)without either
penetration enhancers and ostrich oil. Control formulations
were prepared utilizing vaseline as the matrix with differ-
ent penetration enhancers such as 1% Azone, 2% Azone,
3% Azone, 1% Azone+1% PG and 1% PG, respectively.
Sinomenine(5 mg/g)was then added to control formula-
tions. Test formulation was prepared by the same method
except that ostrich oil was used as vehicle without penetra-
tion enhancers.
2.7 In vitro Skin Permeation studies
2.7.1 Preparation of Isolated Rat Abdominal Skin
The rats were sacrificed by giving excess ether anesthe-
sia. The hairs from the abdominal surface of the rat were
removed by a clipper and isolated skin was surgically
removed from the rats12). The subcutaneous tissue adher-
ing to the skin was separated with help of scalpels and the
dermis side was wiped with isopropyl alcohol to remove
the residual adhering fat. The skin was washed with normal
saline and stored in a deep freezer at -20℃ until use. The
skin was examined under light microscope before the per-
meation experiments to ensure the integrity of the skin13, 14).
2.7.2 Diffusion of sinomenine across rat skin in automatic
diffusion apparatus
The permeability of sinomenine across rat skin in vitro
was studied using automatic diffusion apparatus(Pharma-
copoeia Standard Instrument Factory of Tianjin, China)
fitted with modified Franz diffusion cells at 37±0.5℃
through the use of a circulating water bath. The diffusion
cell consisted of donor and receiver chambers each of ca-
pacity 7 mL with a diffusional area of 1.65 cm2. The treated
skin pieces were mounted over diffusion cells with the
dermal side in contact with the receptor phase. The recep-
tor compartments were filled with phosphate buffered
saline(PBS, pH 6.8)containing 0.02% w/v of sodium azide
to retard microbial growth. The receptor phase was stirred
at 500 rpm with a small magnetic bar to mix the concentra-
tions uniformly. Skins were allowed to equilibrate for 1 h
before experimentation.
The stratum corneum faced the donor chamber filled
with 2.0 g test cream containing sinomenine(5 mg/g).
Samples(2 mL)were withdrawn from the receiver solution
at predetermined time intervals(1, 2, 4, 6, 8, 10 and 24 h).
Sinomenine concentrations were determined by the HPLC
method. Sample volume was immediately replaced to their
marked volumes with fresh receptor medium(maintained
at 37±0.5℃)after each sampling. Addition of solution to
the receiver compartment was performed with great care
to avoid trapping air beneath the dermis samples. All ex-
periments were performed in quadruplicate.
2.8 Data Analysis
The cumulative amount of drug(Q, µg/cm2)permeated
though a unit area was plotted as a function of time. The
steady state flux(Jss, µg/cm
2/h)was determined as the slope
obtained from the linear regression portion of the plot. The
lag time(T, h)was determined by extrapolating the linear
portion of the curve to the abscissa. Permeability coeffi-
cient(Kp, cm/h)was calculated from the ratio of flux to
drug concentration in the donor chamber. In addition, per-
meation profiles were also analyzed by the skin concentra-
tion of drugs(µg/g). The ER was calculated from the Kp
and skin concentration of drugs with enhancer divided by
the same parameter without enhancer(control). All percu-
taneous permeation data are mean±S.D. Statistical signifi-
cance was checked by student’s t test and considered to be
granted at p<0.05.
3 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
3.1 Physicochemical Properties
The physicochemical properties of the permeants, the
molecular weight, solubility and log Po/w of drugs, are
thought to play an important role in determining the pro-
moting activity of penetration enhancers on the permeation
of the drug across the skin3, 15). In this study, the molecular
weight of sinomenine is 329.38 g/mol(Table 1), which is in
the relatively range of 200-500 g/mol. The drug in this mo-
lecular weight range has a potential in transdermal deliv-
ery16). The solubility of the drug, which depends on the
chemical structure of itself and the vehicle, is important in
determining the rate of delivery into the skin. As can be
seen from Table 1, sinomenine has higher solubility in
water at 87.24±8.93 mg/mL and moderately solubility in
PG at 61.36±5.16 mg/mL, respectively. Contrarily, it pos-
sesses low solubility in n-octanol at 3.71±0.24 mg/mL.
The partition coefficient, Po/w, was defined as the ratio of
Table 1 Physicochemical Properties of sinome-
nine.
Properties Results
Molecular weight (g/mol) 329.38
Water solubility (mg/mL) 87.24±8.93
1, 2-PG solubility (mg/mL) 61.36±5.16
PBS (mg/mL) 114.97±9.61
Partition coefficient (Po/w) 0.043
Solubility parameter (MPa1/2) 24.42
X. Liu, T. Chen, X. Liu et al.
J. Oleo Sci. 62, (9) 657-664 (2013)
660
the concentration of the compound in two immiscible
liquid phases such as n-octanol and water. Po/w obtained
from above calculation method, was 0.043. For practical
purposes, the logarithm of the partition coefficient(log Po/w)
which is a measure of how well a substance partitions
between a lipid and water, determines the route of drug
penetration through the skin. By comparison, log Po/w
(-1.37)was not in the specified scope(2~3). The possi-
ble reason was that sinomenine molecule had considerable
water solubility(87.24±8.93 mg/mL, Table 1).
In summary, sinomenine had a low potential of permeat-
ing through the skin to the target, therefore, some addi-
tives such as permeation enhancer should be used in order
to increase the permeation ability of drug.
3.2 Fatty acid composition of ostrich oil
Detailed identification and quantization of the fatty acid
composition in the ostrich oil produced by SFE were per-
formed by GC-MS. As shown in Fig. 2 and Table 2, 18 com-
pounds were detected in the ostrich fat, among which 15
compounds were identified as fatty acids(99.90±0.92%).
The fatty acid composition of ostrich fat was characterized
by 9-octadecenoic acid and hexadecanoic acid as the most
major fatty acids. 9-octadecenoic acid(40.7±0.3%)was
the principal unsaturated fatty acid, followed by 9, 12-octa-
decadience acid(7.38±0.02%)and 9-hexadecenoic acid
(7.13±0.15%). Hexadecanoic acid(32.5±0.3%)was the
predominant saturated fatty acid, followed by octadecanoic
acid(7.43±0.05%). These five fatty acids contributed to
about 95.12%, and other ten minor fatty acids only made
up 4.78% approximately. Many fatty acids are generally
recognized as safe and are approved by the FDA as inactive
ingredients in cosmetic products. The effects of fatty acids
as permeation enhancers have been shown to be depen-
dent on their structure, alkyl chain length, and degree of
saturation17). Unsaturated fatty acids have been shown to
promote higher magnitudes of permeation enhancement
across skin when compared to saturated fatty acids of the
same chain length. This has been attributed to the higher
disrupting nature of the kinked chain of these fatty acids
that would result in a higher magnitude of lipid disruption18-20).
3.3 In vitro Percutaneous Permeation of sinomenine
To further evaluate the penetration effect of ostrich oil
as a vehicle in vitro, the classic permeation enhancers
such as Azone and propylene glycol(PG)were chosen as
positive reference-enhancing promoter in the control for-
mulations. Previous studies demonstrated that Azone is
generally used at low concentrations(1-5% w/v), which
can increase percutaneous permeation of various drugs21).
PG has been extensively used as a solvent for transdermal
formulation, which acts as a solvent for various compounds
leading to an increased thermodynamic activity and en-
hanced “solvent drag” of the drug molecule.
Fig. 3(A)and(B)are examples of HPLC chromatograms
resulting from analysis of the effect of ostrich oil on perme-
ation of sinomenine across rat skin after 1 h and 24 h. A
significant increasing height of the peak in sample collected
from 1 to 24 h indicated that ostrich oil has higher perme-
ation enhancement on sinomenine. Permeation profiles for
sinomenine across rat abdominal skin in ostrich oil and
control formulations containing other permeation enhanc-
Fig. 2 GC chromatograms of ostrich oil obtained by SFE.
Penetration effect of Ostrich Oil as a Promising Vehicle on Transdermal Delivery of Sinomenine
J. Oleo Sci. 62, (9) 657-664 (2013)
661
ers are shown in Fig. 4. All results are expressed as means
±standard deviations. The results revealed that ostrich oil
as vehicle significantly enhanced transdermal drug delivery
of sinomenine. Among all the permeation enhancers evalu-
ated, 2% Azone had the highest enhancing effect on the
permeation of sinomenine through the rat skin. The pene-
tration effect of ostrich oil on sinomenine was higher than
other enhancers except 2% Azone. When 1% PG used as
an enhancer in the control formulation, there was no pro-
moting effect on the permeation of sinomenine. The result
of blank control experiment had no difference compared
with that of the control formulation containing 1% PG as
permeation enhancer. The control formulation containing
only 1% Azone existed lower enhancing effect on the per-
meation of sinomenine. Moreover, the combination of 1%
Azone plus 1% PG used in the control formulation, the
percutaneous permeation of sinomenine was obviously in-
creased. The finding suggested that the enhancer activity
of Azone may be increased by using cosolvents including
PG22). As shown in Fig. 4, with the increase of Azone con-
centration from 1% to 2%(w/v), accumulative permeated
amount of sinomenine increased, but decreased when
Azone concentration reached to 3%(w/v). This result indi-
cated that there was an optimum concentration for Azone
to achieve the best permeation-enhancing effect23). Beyond
the apparent “optimum” Azone concentration(2% w/v),
the permeation of sinomenine did not increase further.
The steady state flux of sinomenine obtained after per-
meation enhancers treatment is in the following decreasing
order: 2% Azone>ostrich oil>1% Azone+1% PG>1%
Azone>3% Azone(p<0.05, Table 3). Moreover, it can
also be clearly seen that ostrich oil exhibits better enhance-
ment activity(ER=24.31, p<0.05). Ostrich oil h