June 1996
®
TOPSwitch®Power Supply Design
Techniques for EMI and Safety
Application Note AN-15
Offline switching power supplies have high voltage and high
current switching waveforms that generate Electromagnetic
Interference (EMI) in the form of both conducted and radiated
emissions. Consequently, all off-line power supplies must be
designed to attenuate or suppress EMI emissions below
commonly acceptable limits.
This application note presents design techniques that reduce
conducted EMI emissions in TOPSwitch power supplies below
normally specified limits. Properly designed transformers, PC
boards, and EMI filters not only reduce conducted EMI emissions
but also suppress radiated EMI emissions and improve EMI
susceptibility. These techniques can also be used in applications
with DC input voltages such as Telecom and Television Cable
Communication (or Cablecom). Refer to AN-14 and AN-20 for
additional information. The following topics will be presented:
• EMI Specifications for North America, European
Community, and Germany
• Measuring Conducted Emissions with a LISN
• Peak, Quasi-Peak, and Average Detection Methods
• Safety Principles
• EMI Filter Components
• Flyback Power Supply EMI Signature Waveforms
• Filter Analysis
• Power Cord Resonances
• Transformer Construction Techniques
• Suppression Techniques
• General Purpose TOPSwitch EMI Filters
• EMI Filter PC Layout Issues
• Practical Considerations
Figure 1. FCC Class A and B Limits (Quasi Peak).
120
A
m
pl
itu
de
(d
Bµ
V)
100
80
60
40
20
0
0.01 0.1 1
Frequency (MHz)
10 100
PI
-1
62
3-
11
16
95
EN55022A QP
EN55022A AVG
EN55022B AVG
EN55022B QP
Figure 2. EN55022 Class A and B Limits (Average and Quasi Peak).
120
A
m
pl
itu
de
(d
Bµ
V)
100
80
60
40
20
0
0.01 0.1 1
Frequency (MHz) 10
100
PI
-1
62
2-
11
16
95
FCCA QP
FCCB QP
120
A
m
pl
itu
de
(d
Bµ
V)
100
80
60
40
20
0
0.01 0.1 1
Frequency (MHz)
10 100
PI
-1
83
4-
04
22
96
Vfg243 QP
Vfg46 AVG
120
A
m
pl
itu
de
(d
Bµ
V)
100
80
60
40
20
0
0.01 0.1 1
Frequency (MHz)
10 100
Vfg243 QP
Vfg1046 QP
(VDE0871B QP)
PI
-1
62
4-
11
16
95
Figure 4. Vfg243 (Quasi Peak) and Vfg46 (Average) Class B
Limits.Figure 3. Vfg1046 and Vfg243 Class B Limits (Quasi Peak).
AN-15
A
6/962
Safety is a vital issue which determines EMI filter component
selection, the transformer reinforced insulation system, and PC
board primary to secondary spacing. In fact, safety is an integral
part of the power supply/EMI filter design and is difficult to
discuss as a separate issue. Throughout this application note,
design guidance will also be presented for meeting safety
requirements in TOPSwitch power supplies.
EMI Specifications
The applicable EMI specification must be identified for the
intended product family and target market. In the United States,
the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) regulates
EMI specifications. Canadian specifications are similar to FCC
specifications. Figure 1 shows the conducted emissions limits
governed by FCC rules, Part 15, subpart J. Note that specification
limits are given only for quasi-peak detection methods. A
recent part 15 amendment allows manufacturers to use the
limits contained in C.I.S.P.R. Publication 22 as an alternative
when testing devices for compliance(1).
The member countries of the European Community (EC) have
established a harmonized program for electromagnetic
compatibility. EN55022 for Information Technology
Equipment is one of the first harmonized documents. EN55022
together with companion measurement document C.I.S.P.R
Publication 22 set the conducted emission limits shown in
Figure 2 for information technology products marketed to the
European Community. In fact, EN55022 limits are the same as
C.I.S.P.R Publication 22 limits. Note that class A and class B
specification limits are given for both average and quasi-peak
detection methods(2) (3).
Figure 3 shows the well-known and most stringent VDE 0871
specification (narrow band limits) for German markets which
has traditionally been the design target. German regulation Vfg
1046/1984 requires Information technology or Electronic Data
Processing Equipment to meet the VDE 0871 class B narrow
band limits from 10 kHz to 30 MHz. Note that specification
limits are given only for quasi-peak detection methods. When
marketing products only in Germany, there is a choice between
meeting the regulation requirements of Vfg 1046/1984 or the
new German regulation Vfg 243/1991 (as updated by Vfg 46/
1992) which has relaxed limits from 10 kHz to 150 kHz and is
harmonized with EN55022 from 150 kHz to 30 MHz. Vfg243/
1991 sets quasi-peak limits and Vfg 46/1992 adds mean or
average limits as shown in Figure 4. Figure 3 also shows
Vfg243/1991 class B quasi-peak limits to compare with
VDE0871(4) (5) (6). The EMI filter designed to meet VDE 0871
(per Vfg 1046/1984) will generally be higher cost than the EMI
PI-1625-111695
VSL
VSN
LF
LF
CF
CF
LINE
+
_
+
_
INPUT OUTPUT
NEUTRAL
CC
CC
RSL
RSN
Figure 5. Line Impedance Stabilization Network (LISN).
filter designed to meet Vfg/243 regulation requirements.
Measuring Conducted Emissions
Details of testing apparatus and methodology are governed by
the various EMI regulations, but share the same general concept.
Conducted emissions measurements are made with a Line
Impedance Stabilization Network (LISN). Figure 5 shows the
effective filter, represented by LF and CF, inside the LISN which
passes line frequency currents but forces higher frequency
power supply conducted emission currents to flow through
coupling capacitor CC and sense resistor RS. A spectrum
analyzer or EMI receiver reads the current emission signal
magnitude as sensed voltages VSL and VSN across RSL and RSN
in dBµV.
A
6/96
AN-15
3
LISN Bonded to
Reference Plane Non-conducting
Table
40 cm 80 cm 80 cm
80 cm
minimum
height
PI-1626-111695
Unit
Under Test Load
This Edge Flush Up
Against Vertical
Reference Plane
PI-1627-111695
0ACCURRENT
AC
IN
CIN
L
L
V+
V-
First
Pulse Steady State Peak Current
Conduction Time
≅ 3 mS
ID
Figure 7. Differential Mode Currents Charging Input Capacitor CIN.
Figure 6. Typical Conducted Emissions Precompliance Test Set Up.
Figure 6 shows a typical conducted emissions pre-compliance
test setup on a wooden table at least 80 cm high constructed with
non-metallic fasteners(7). The unit under test, LISNs, and load
are all placed 40 cm from the edge of the table as shown. Six
foot cables are used between the unit under test and both the
LISN on the AC input and the load on the DC output. The LISN
and load are each located 80 cm from the unit under test with
excess cable bundled non-inductively. The edge of the table is
placed flush against a vertical reference plane at least two
meters square. The LISN is bonded to the reference plane with
a low impedance, high frequency grounding strap or braided
cable.
In applications where the power supply and load are located in
the same physical package, the cable can be omitted between
the unit under test and the load.
For design, investigation and precompliance testing, a spectrum
analyzer is highly recommended compared to EMI receivers
which are more expensive and more difficult to use. For
conducted and radiated emissions testing, the spectrum analyzer
should have a frequency range of 10 kHz to 1 Ghz, wide range
of resolution bandwidths (including C.I.S.P.R. specified
bandwidths of 200 Hz, 9 kHz, 120 kHz), built in quasi-peak
detector, video filter bandwidth adjustment capability down to
3 Hz or below for average measurements, maximum hold for
peak measurements, and an accurate and temperature
compensated local oscillator capable of centering a 100 kHz
signal in the display with insignificant frequency drift. The HP
8591EM and Tektronix 2712 (option 12)(8)are two examples of
lower cost spectrum analyzers sufficient for conducted emissions
precompliance testing.
Peak, Quasi-Peak, and Average
Detection
Power supplies operating from the 50 or 60 Hz AC mains use
a bridge rectifier and large filter capacitor to create a high
voltage DC bus from the AC input voltage as shown in
Figure 7. The bridge rectifier conducts input current for only
a short time near the peak of AC mains voltage. Actual
conduction time is typically 3 mS out of effective line frequency
periods of 8.3 to 10 mS which defines an effective “line
frequency duty cycle” of 30% to 36%. Conducted emission
currents can flow in the AC mains leads (and are sensed by the
LISN) only during the bridge rectifier conduction time. The
conducted emissions signal is actually applied to the spectrum
analyzer or receiver detector input only during bridge diode
conduction time which defines a “gating pulse” with pulse
repetitive frequency (PRF)(8)(9) equal to the AC mains frequency
(50 or 60 Hz) and “line frequency duty cycle” just defined. The
“gating pulse” effect due to bridge rectifier conduction time
causes the measured signal magnitude to change depending on
whether peak, quasi-peak, or average detection methods are
used.
A spectrum analyzer or EMI receiver displays the RMS value
of the signal(9). For example, a 100 kHz continuous sinusoidal
AN-15
A
6/964
voltage when viewed on an oscilloscope may have a peak
voltage of 1 Volt and hence an RMS voltage of 0.707 Volts. The
spectrum analyzer (with 50 Ω input) will display a value for this
100 kHz signal of 0.707 volts (or 117 dBµV or 10 dBmW)
regardless of which detection method is used (peak, quasi-peak,
or average) because the signal is continuous, narrow band, and
not modulated or gated. If the signal was broadband, modulated,
gated at a duty cycle, or in some other way not continuous, the
displayed RMS value will change with the detection method.
The measured display will then be the magnitude of an equivalent
continuous sinusoidal signal with an RMS value equal to the
RMS content of the LISN signal measured at the output of the
detector stage.
Peak detection is the simplest and fastest method when measuring
conducted emissions. Resolution bandwidth is set to 200 Hz for
measurements from 10 kHz to 150 kHz and set to 9 kHz for
measurements from 150 kHz to 30 MHz. Sweep times are
relatively low. When displaying emissions in real time with no
averaging, the peaks are not constant but change in magnitude
with each measurement sweep due to the bridge conduction
gating pulse effect described above. Most spectrum analyzers
have a “maximum hold” feature which displays the highest
peak occurring over many measurement sweeps. The peak
detector measures the magnitude of the largest signal occurring
during the bridge conduction gating pulse.
The average detector is simply a low pass filter with corner
frequency sufficiently below the gating pulse repetitive
frequency or PRF. In typical spectrum analyzers, the video
filter bandwidth can be reduced to 30 Hz or below to average the
signal but the sweep time must be increased for a calibrated
measurement. For test purposes, the full conducted emissions
range starting at 10 kHz (or 150 kHz or 450 kHz, depending on
the regulation) up to 30 MHz should first be examined with a
peak detection measurement. Peak detected emissions with
insufficient margin compared to the regulation average limit
should be centered on the spectrum analyzer display with the
lowest possible frequency span per division setting before
reducing video bandwidth and performing the average
measurement sweep(10). Figure 8 shows typical conducted
emissions from 10 kHz to 500 kHz with both peak detection and
average detection. Note that peak detection picked up an
envelope of high order harmonics from line frequency
rectification in addition to the fundamental and first three
harmonics of the 100 kHz switching frequency.
The quasi-peak detector is designed to indicate the subjective
annoyance level of interference. As an analogy, a soft noise that
happens every second is much more annoying than a loud noise
110
A
m
pl
itu
de
(d
Bµ
V)
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
100 200
Frequency (KHz)
Peak Data
Average Data
300 500400
PI
-1
62
8-
11
16
95
Figure 8. Peak Data vs Average Data.
that happens every hour. A quasi peak-detector (actually a
calibrated, intermediate bandwidth video filter) behaves as a
leaky peak detector that partially discharges between input
signal pulses. The lower the pulse repetitive frequency (PRF),
the greater the dB differential between the peak and quasi-peak
measured response (8) (9).
Quasi-peak and average detection methods will always give a
lower measured value compared to peak detection. If a peak
detector measurement meets the average or mean specification
limit with sufficient margin, additional measurements using
average detection are not necessary. When no average limit is
specified, if the peak measurement meets the quasi-peak limit
with sufficient margin, additional measurements using quasi-
peak detection are not necessary. In general, when testing
TOPSwitch power supplies to the C.I.S.P.R. Publication 22,
EN55022, or Vfg 243/91(and Vfg 46/92) limits, peak measured
data usually meets the quasi-peak limit but, in some areas, may
have insufficient margin when compared with the average
limit. In this case, further measurement is necessary using
average detection.
Safety Principles
Safety principles must be examined before proceeding further
with EMI filter concepts because safety requirements place
several constraints on EMI filter design.
Virtually all equipment including computers, printers,
televisions, television decoders, video games, battery chargers,
etc., must be safety recognized by meeting the safety standard
for the intended market and carrying the appropriate safety
mark. Safety principles are very similar among the various
standards. This application note will focus on the electric shock
hazard requirements of one popular standard, IEC950(11).
A
6/96
AN-15
5
The European International Electrotechnical Commission
Standard IEC950 entitled “Safety of Information Technology
Equipment Including Electrical Business Equipment” provides
detailed requirements for safe equipment design. Application
of IEC950 is intended to prevent injury or damage due to
hazards including electric shock, energy hazards, fire hazards,
fire, mechanical and heat hazards, radiation hazards, and
chemical hazards. IEC950 specifies the following definitions
and requirements applicable to TOPSwitch power supplies.
(This is only a partial list of the key requirements targeted
specifically at typical TOPSwitch power supply
implementations. The appropriate IEC950 section is identified
by parentheses.)
IEC950 Definitions (Applicable to TOPSwitch Power
Supplies):
(Introduction): Electric shock is due to current passing through
the human body. Currents of approximately 1 mA can cause a
reaction in persons of good health and may cause indirect
danger due to involuntary reaction. Higher currents can have
more damaging effects. Voltages up to about 40 V peak, or 60
VDC are not generally regarded as dangerous under dry
conditions, but parts which have to be touched or handled
should be at earth ground potential or properly insulated.
(1.2.4.1): Class I Equipment: equipment where protection
against electric shock is achieved by:
a) using basic insulation, and also
b) providing a means of connecting to the protective
earthing conductor in the building wiring those conductive
parts that are otherwise capable of assuming hazardous
voltages if the basic insulation fails.
(1.2.4.2): Class II Equipment: equipment in which protection
against electric shock does not rely on basic insulation only, but
in which additional safety precautions, such as double insulation
or reinforced insulation, are provided, there being no provision
for protective earthing or reliance upon installation conditions.
(1.2.8.1): Primary circuit: An internal circuit which is directly
connected to the external supply mains or other equivalent
source. In a TOPSwitch power supply, this includes the EMI
filter, discrete or common mode chokes, bridge rectifier,
transformer primary, TOPSwitch, and any components
connected to TOPSwitch such as primary bias windings and
optocoupler output transistors.
(1.2.8.2): Secondary circuit: A circuit which has no direct
connection to primary power (except through properly selected
Y-capacitors) and derives its power from a transformer.
(1.2.8.5): Safety extra-low voltage (SELV) circuit: A secondary
circuit which is so designed and protected that under normal and
single fault conditions, the voltage between any two accessible
parts, or between one accessible part and the equipment protective
earthing terminal for class I equipment, does not exceed a safe
value.
(1.2.9.2): Basic Insulation: insulation to provide basic protection
against electric shock.
(1.2.9.3): Supplementary Insulation: Independent insulation
applied in addition to basic insulation in order to ensure protection
against electric shock in the event of a failure of the basic
insulation.
(1.2.9.4): Double Insulation: Insulation comprising both basic
insulation and supplementary insulation.
(1.2.9.5): Reinforced Insulation: A single insulation system
which provides a degree of protection against electric shock
equivalent to double insulation.
(1.2.9.6): Working voltage: The highest voltage to which the
insulation under consideration is, or can be, subjected when the
equipment is operating at its rated voltage under conditions of
normal use.
(1.2.9.7): Tracking: the progressive formation of conducting
paths on the surface of a solid insulating material (such as PC
board or transformer bobbin) due to the combined effects of
electric stress and electrolytic contamination on this surface.
(1.2.10.1): Creepage distance: the shortest path between two
conductive parts, or between a conductive part and the bounding
surface of the equipment, measured along the surface of the
insulation. In a TOPSwitch power supply, the most important
creepage distance is between all primary circuits and all
secondary circuits (typically 5mm to 6 mm).
(1.2.10.2): Clearance: the shortest distance between two
conductive parts, or between a conductive part and the bounding
surface of the equipment, measured through air.
(1.2.11.1): Safety Isolating Transformer: the power transformer
in which windings supplying SELV circuits are isolated from
other windings (such as primary and primary bias windings)
such that an insulation breakdown either is unlikely or does not
cause a hazardous condition on SELV windings.
AN-15
A
6/966
IEC950 Requirements (Applicable to TOPSwitch Power
Supplies)
(1.4.5): In determining the most unfavorable supply voltage for
a test, the following variables shall be taken into account:
• multiple rated voltages
• extremes of rated voltage ranges
• tolerance on rated voltage as specified by the manufacturer.
If a tolerance is not specified, it shall be taken as +6% and
- 10%.
(1.6.5): Equipment intended to operate directly from the mains
supply shall be designed for a minimum supply tolerance of
+6%, -10%.
(2.1.10): Equipment shall be so designed that at an external
point of disconnection of the mains supply, there is no risk of
electric shock from stored charge on capacitors connected to the
mains circuit. Equipment shall be considered to comply if any
capacitor having a rated capacitance exceeding 0.1 uF and
connected to the external mains circuit, has a means of discharge
resulting in a time constant not exceeding 1 second for pluggable
equipment type A (non-industrial plugs and socket-outlets).
This requirement specifically applies to any EMI filter capacitor
connected directly across the AC mains which could cause a
shock hazard on the exposed prongs of an unplugged power
cord.
(5.2.2): Earth Leakage Current: Maximum