论柯恩的“纯粹”一神教

论柯恩的“纯粹”一神教 论柯恩的“纯粹”一神教 3?? ????????7s????7g?????? ?,?6???????. ?????????P??????7s????7g???????q?????f?????g???9???????M????FH7s????7g?? ???????????q?h?g???????M?c?m???h?g???j???????M???????h?g?????p???????M?c???? ?????q?????5?i?????????MFH???q????7s????7g???????c???????????f?y?????????g?? ???????F?a??FH ???4???P???????????????M?a?M ???m?????P?,?6???c???s?C?e?M??????F3?????0???C?b?????.?c???s?C?e?M?????? ???????CF3???s?M?????f???l???????,???9???????,????FH ???,?????????CHermannCohen?o?q???????f???????h?????q?lF3?????????????4?????c?????? ?p?R???????????????f???????? B? ?????????7???????f???????n???c?c?,?j???g?????d???0???7???? ???????b?????????c???????f???????????f???c?????????????????????????????c B? ?????????????g ???c?D?????c?P?????????????l?????F???I?????g?????o???????c??????????FH?j?h???B?????????7 ???????E?c???????g?????o?????????f???????????P???????????????c?a?M??????????FH?c???????? ?????o???f?c??????7s????7g??????FH ??F37s????7g?????????a?????? ?????F7s????7g?c?????????P???F?????c???F??????7s?????a?M7g???E??FH?????????????????1 ???????????c?????????????????????Y?q?o?????????????,??FH?????????c?????a?a?M?????.???? ??FH?????????????????????????????????????????????????c???????h???c???R?q?????q??????FH?? ?q?7???????????a?????Y?y?????????????????c?c7s????7g???j???????????????q?????0?????g???? ??FH?????c?????j??????????7s????7g???????7?????????????????????h?c?a?B?m???C?????7?R???? ????7s????7g?????????g???c???j???????h?????????????f?????f?????g??FH ??F3?????q7s????7g?????? ?????????c7s????7g???????9?????????????????????????a?M?????c?l?m?c???????j?????????v ?a???9FH?c???????????q???f???9???????????c?B???q?????????f?????v?a????????????????????FH ?????a???f?????????v?a???????c???????????L?I?h?????????????j???????????????M???F??FH?? ???c???????????q?????a?M?????????????c?????????????????????q?P?????h?g?R?q?R?h?gFH???f ?????????u???i????????????????7s?????h?g???a?????R7gFH?j???B?f?????9?????e???a?M???????? ?jFH???q?c?j???????????????????h???????M?E???????????????a??FH???????????h?g???????????? B?EncyclopaediaJudaica,Vol.5,KeterPublishingHouse,ltd,2007,P18. B?EliezerBerkovits?cMajorThemesintheModernPhilosophiesofJudaism,KTAVPublishingHouse,Inc,1975,P1. k????q?u?????????f???,?? 4 2011???I2?0 ??FH?c?????????????c?i???y???a?h?g?E???????c?y???P?????M???????h?gFH?????c?h?g???????y?? ???????c???????????????0????????Fh???????f?????a?M????FE B? ???????E?c???h?g???????????a?? ?B?f??????????FH???????q?????h?g?I?????c?????????q?????h?g?????M??FH ?I???f?????c?k?????????c?i?????y???????h?g?I??FH???????u???????h?g?I???q?n???????o ?h?g???o???s???c?????q7s????7g?????????????????I???f???????p???c???R?q???c???????q?????? ???h?g???s???c?????h?g?????????s???c?c?????s???R?q?h?g???????M?Cuniqueness?oFH?????M?q?? ?????b???????c?????q???l?h?g???????????????jFH?????????F???????????t?c?????q?j???P?????? ???????????E?g?e???????MFH???D???????????a???????c?P?????????????d???f???c?P?f?????????c ?j???????q???????R?q?????M???y?P?M??????FH?j?????E???c???D???????R???????.FH?o???????? ???P7s?????j?P?????9?0?????????y???q?????????y?P?M?c?c?,???m???????c???????????????l?m?? ?M?????Y???c???q?j?l?m???9?f?A??????????????FH?????c???????????q?c?P?????????????c?????L ?????????h?g???????????c???????c???L???h?g?c??????????FH7g B? ???l???c???????h?g???o???p?? ?q?I?????h???c?????????M???Y?????????????q?c???????????????c???q???l?????????q?c????F3?c ???Y??????FH ?I???f?????q?????h?g?????MFH?????????c???M???????????y???q???????????e???P7s?????? ?????j???h?g???I?j???9?c???q???y???0???????????????????h?g???I?j?P?????????q???????0???P ???????????c???????????????????o??FH7g B? ???????i???y???E???c???????Y???????????????h?g?? ???M?c?????????M???????h?g???????MFH???????q???????M???f?????h?g???I?j?c?????????c???q?? ???????????c?????????j?????q?????P?????????????h?gFH?????????j?????h?o?B???c?????q?c?y?q ???????c?q???R?h?gFH?.?m?c?????n?F???c?y?q?j?P?????M???????????p???h???????h?g?c?c?q???R ?????p?????h?gFH???????q?c???????M?????P?????????n??????FH???C?B?m?c?R?h?g?????R?q?R???f ?e???c?R?q?????????????????????????e?????h?gFH ?oF37s????7g???????????I?????? ???I?????c?????????????????R?q???f???????????????h??????FH?????????h?????????I???o ?????c???f?????q?R???????0?????j?3???CFranzRosenzweig?o?l???jFh???????0FE?9???d??FH B? ?? ?q?c?j???P?F???c?j?????????????????P7s???y???F7v7v??????????????FH7g B? ???p?????c?????j?.?? ?0???9?????f?????????????????????????y?j???????e?????5?c?j?????I?????a???9?c???f???????? ???B???q???????????j???????E?????M?7????FH?c?????M?7?????c?j?i???E???c???q??????7s????7g ???????????I?p???h??F3?y????7s????7g???????????????y?cFH?????n???P7s?????q?3?c?????????P ?j???????????p?E???????????c???????R?y???????????f?????????????MFH7g B? ???????u?????????? B?HermannCohen,ReligionofReasonoutoftheSourcesofJudaism,FrederickUngarPublishingCo.,NewYork,1972. B?HermannCohen,ReligionofReasonoutoftheSourcesofJudaism,FrederickUngarPublishingCo.,NewYork,1972,P35. B?HermannCohen,ReligionofReasonoutoftheSourcesofJudaism,FrederickUngarPublishingCo.,NewYork,1972?cP95. B??????????????e?PFranzRosenzweig??Fh???????0FE?CStarofRedemption,UniversityofNotreDamePress,1985?o?????? ?I?o???aFH B??????????????e??????????ReligionofReasonoutoftheSourcesofJudaism??????????FH B?HermannCohen,ReligionofReasonoutoftheSourcesofJudaism,FrederickUngarPublishingCo.,NewYork,1972?cP364. 44 5?? ????????7s????7g?????? ?p?E?????????c?j?????????????c?R?q???Y?????h?g?c???c????????????FH???Y?c???????????????? ???????L?I???h?c???????0???a??FH ???Y?c???????P?T?j?????I?????????????d???????o????????????????FH?????????n???P7s?h?g ?I?M?9??????7K?????M7t?.7K?????M7t?CBeyonderness?o???????????9???????????c?????????9???q?? ?b?CPhilo?o?j?h?g?????Y?????????????r???CLogos?o???q?j?h?g?????????????????????.??FH?c?D ?F?c?h?g???????M??????????7K???C7t?Cincorporation?o???o???????CTrinity?o???????M?c?????l?m?? ?????h?g?????????????MFH7g B? ?j???c?????m???F?p???F???????????????F???c????????????FH???d ?????????????c?j?????E???c?????????q???f?????bFH???q?c?o?????????????P7s???r?????????q?? ?????????????????????a???????????????9?6?Y??????FH7g B? ?????????b???????r???????j?y?????? ??7s???????q??????7g?c B? ?c?,????????????FH???r?????????y???U?????h?g???????M?c?c?,?????h ?g?c?????????R???????d??????????FH ???.?c???????????????????d?????h?g???????M???U??FH?5???????c?????????????f?L?I?M?? ?????q?0?b?P???????c???F????FH?c?P?????????F???????g???I???R?q?j?????h?g?????????9??FH?? ???c?????q???????y????????FH ??F37s????7g?????????????5?i?? ?j???????????c???????f?q?????????d?d?????c???f?y?????????o?d?d?u??????FH?????????? ?f?????f?7???????????????f?????????f?y?????????????????p???c???P?i?q?????????e????????FH ?i???????c???????????c???Y?q??????????7s????7g?????????E???a?y????FH ?j?????E???c7s????7g???????????????r?c?????????I???????????.?c???????????m?????????? ???c?????????m???3???????????MFH?????h?E?c?????????M?????q?????c???????c???f?y?????????? ???C???c???????h?c???q?????5?i?????????M???????????????f?y??????FH?o?????????a???c???f?y ?????????????c?j?????h???????q???p???????????????????i?????????????c?c?j?a???h ???????q?i ?????????????????????????i????????????FH???q???????????????????c???????q?j?i?????????h?? ?d??FH?i?????d?????????????c?c???????????????i????????????FH?????????c???R???????f?y???? ?????a??????FH???q?c?????????c?????c???????j?a???h???q?j?????h???q???y???P??FH?????c?? ?a???h?E?c?????5?i???y?c???????i???c?????y?c???r?j?????q?h?g??7s?o?i7gFH?????????o?i???E ???c???????????c?R?q?c?h?g???????o???????5???c???h?g???y?????q?????5?????h?g?c?c?q?????? ???h?gFH???u?h?g???o???????5?????I?????A???q???????37s????7g??????FH?????n???P7s?i???M?? ?y?q?????M?????c???y?q?1?????c?????a???I?????y?j?i???M???9?b???????j???????????????????? ???????????e?????c?????????F?a?????F??FH???R?q?????5?????o?i???A??FH7g B? ???R?q???c?????5 ?????o?i???????????q?????????c?????q????????????????FH???q?a?????5?i???????F???????????? ?????h?c?????h?c?????5?i???????d?????????????d?q?c?????c???????????????????5?i?????????? ?q?c????FH?????c7s????7g?????????????M???????????5?i?????????M?P?????5?i???y????????FH?? B??????????????eReligionofReasonoutoftheSourcesofJudaism?????I????FH B?HermannCohen,ReligionofReasonoutoftheSourcesofJudaism,FrederickUngarPublishingCo.,NewYork,1972?cP239. B??????????q?????????????h???????????Cscientificphilosophy?oFH B?HermannCohen,ReligionofReasonoutoftheSourcesofJudaism,FrederickUngarPublishingCo.,NewYork,1972?cP363. 4 6?? ?.?????????.2011???I2?0 ???F?0?j?????g?????????Y???????????R?q?????5?i???j?????????i??????????????????FH???1?c?? ?????h?E?c?I???1?.???M?K?????????????f?y?????????g???????c?????????i?????c?????F??????FH ?j?I???1?.???M?K?a?????????????????????c?i???????????q?????a???c?????????i??????????F3?0 ???????????c???????????F?????.F3???l???????h?c?????????.?????i?????????f???????????????? ?????c?.???M?K???a???c?g?????????????????i???????y???y???????i??F3???????????????????? ???c?????c?k????????F3?k?????a????????????????FH?????P???????c?I???1?.???M?K???l???????? ???R?q?h?????????g??????FH ??F37s????7g???????9???y?????????? ??????7s????7g???????????j?????????E???q???????c???????j?????9?????o???????c?????y ?????M?????????j???l?h?g?????????9FH?i???????c???l?h?g???????????M???????a???B?f?????c?? ?f?q?a???????h???c???????????????q?a?M???????b?7?c???????c?j?????????h???l?h?g?????????? ???j???????e?????b?????f?????q?????h???c?j??????????????FH?j?????E???c?h?g?????M?q?????? ?????????c?R?????c???????q???????c???R?????c???????????q??????FH???????y?q???????c?????q ?????F?r???r?D?????????????Y??FH?????q???0???????????????Y???c?????????????????????Y???c ?B???q?c??????????FH?????????????c?????R?????c?????y?????M???????????????? ???U?b?c?B???q ?f?????????????U?bFH?????????F???o?????f???q?v?a???????f??????????????FH???????q???3???E ???c?????o???f?????z??????????FH?i???????c???f?????z?????????q?f???c?P?????????c???o?j ???????c?????q?f??FH B? ?j???????h?c?????????????R?p???????????v?a???????q?C?????????c?f?? ?????????????o???0?zFH???q?c???????????????????8???E???c?i?????????????f???????????????? ???c???R?q??????????FH???h???????c?U?b?????q?????f?????????????b?c???I???????q?y???????? ????FH?????????q?c?????????E???????????????????l?h?g???????????y????????FH?????j???c???? ???q?f?????c?????????y?q?f????????FH???????L?I?????????m?A???h?g??????FH?????k???F???? ???c???????mF3?????????m?I???????q???3???c?c???o?h?g???????F??????FH?????????????????c?? ???f???0???h?g???????c?????j???l?h?g???????9?c?h?g?R?y?????????q???f????FH?????????????c ?C?????????????????q???????f???????c???q?c?e???F???f???f?i???????????c?????????????f???? ???????c???c?a???????????????????l?F???????f??FH?????q?????????m?????c?P???q???????????? ?????????f?????o?j?????????????????E????????????????????????FH???q?c???????y?q?????????? ?????c?i???????c???????D?????????q?????I???1?.???M?K???l?????????????C?????????????a???? ???????c???????????????f???????????o???F???????9????????FH?????c???????????j?????????y?? ?y?????????????????????c?????j???.?????????c?????y???y?c???f?.??????FH ?C?z???.???q?9?o B?EliezerBerkovits,MajorThemesintheModernPhilosophiesofJudaism,KTAVPublishingHouse,Inc,1975,P3. 4