FRIDAY, APRIL 27, 2012 THE GLOBAL EDITION OF THE NEW YORK TIMES GLOBAL.NYTIMES.COM
FOR SUBSCRIPTION INFORMATION, CALL:
00800 44 48 78 27
or e-mail us at subs@iht.com
. . . .
Algeria Din 175 Ivory Coast CFA 2.200
Andorra ¤ 3.00 Morocco Dh 22
Antilles ¤ 3.00 Senegal CFA 2.200
Cameroon CFA 2.200 Tunisia Din 3.200
Gabon CFA 2.200 Reunion ¤ 3.50
NEWSSTAND PRICES
France ¤ 3.00
IN THIS ISSUE
No. 40,164
Books 11
Business 14
Crossword 13
Culture 10
Sports 12
Views 8
PENALTY KICKS
NOWAY TO END
A SOCCER MATCH
PAGE 12 | SPORTS
WORLD STAGE
A REVOLUTION
IN ‘LIVE’ OPERA
PAGE 10 | CULTURE
DIGITAL PRE-NUP
RULES FORWHAT
TO SHARE ONLINE
PAGE 15 | BUSINESS WITH
CURRENCIES STOCK INDEXES
OIL
NEW YORK, THURSDAY 1:30PM THURSDAY
NEW YORK, THURSDAY 1:30PM
PREVIOUS
s Euro €1= $1.3230 $1.3220
s Pound £1= $1.6180 $1.6170
s Yen $1= ¥80.830 ¥81.260
— S. Franc $1= SF0.9080 SF0.9080
s The Dow 1:30pm 13,148.88 +0.44%
s FTSE 100 close 5,748.72 +0.52%
s Nikkei 225 close 9,561.83 +0.01%
s Light sweet crude $104.52 +$1.26
VIEWS
China grows up
China has reached a stage at which all
‘‘miracle economies’’ have slowed. A
smooth downshift in growthmakes the
country amore normal rival, writes
Ruchir Sharma. PAGE 8
Nicholas D. Kristof
Could the brain autopsy of a 27-year-old
formerU.S.marinewho did two tours in
Iraq help explain the epidemic of
suicides and other troubles experienced
by veterans of America’swars? PAGE 9
COMING THIS WEEKEND
Keeping Swiss watches Swiss
Amove to tighten labeling rules for
Swiss watches, a pillar of the country’s
economy, has fueled a broader debate
over what constitutes ‘‘Swissness.’’
Top of the heap
Samuel L. Jackson, arguably the coolest
and busiest actor on the planet, holds
the GuinnessWorld Record as ‘‘the
highest-grossing film actor’’ of all time.
Ful l currency rates Page 17
Ex-president
of Liberia is
convicted of
war crimes
THE HAGUE
BYMARLISE SIMONS
Charles G. Taylor, the former president
of Liberia and once a powerful warlord,
was convicted on Thursday by an inter-
national tribunal of 11 counts of plan-
ning, aiding and abetting war crimes
committed in Sierra Leone during its
civil war in the 1990s.
He is the first head of state to be con-
victedbyan international court since the
Nuremberg trials afterWorldWar II.
The ruling, announced by Presiding
Judge Richard Lussick, said Mr. Taylor
was guilty of involvement in crimes
against humanity and war crimes, in-
cludingmurder, rape, slaveryand theuse
of child soldiers. But the court said the
prosecution had failed to prove that Mr.
Taylor had direct command responsibili-
ty for the atrocities in the indictment.
The conflict in Sierra Leone became
notorious for its gruesome tactics, in-
cluding the calculated mutilation of
thousands of civilians, the widespread
use of drugged child soldiers and the
mining of diamonds to pay for guns and
ammunition.
A new, sinister rebel vocabulary poin-
ted to the horrors: applying ‘‘a smile’’
meant cutting off the upper and lower
lips of a victim; giving ‘‘long sleeves’’
meant hacking off the hands; andgiving
‘‘short sleeves’’ meant cutting the arm
above the elbow.
Prosecutors saidMr. Taylor’s involve-
ment in the war was motivated not by
ideologybut by a simple quest for power
andmoney— ‘‘pure avarice,’’ said Dav-
id M. Crane, the American prosecutor
who indicted him in 2003.
Rebels supplied Mr. Taylor with ‘‘a
continuous supply’’ of diamonds, often
in exchange of arms and ammunition,
the court found, allowing him to send
what prosecutors said amounted to
hundreds of millions of dollars to off-
shore companies. Yet investigators nev-
er unraveled the web hiding this pre-
sumed fortune and Mr. Taylor pleaded
penury, leaving the court to pay the bill
for a defense that cost $100,000 per
month in lawyers, staff and rent.
Still, the trial has brought ‘‘a sense of
relief,’’ said Ibrahim Tommy, who leads
the Center for Accountability and Rule
of Law, a rights group in Freetown, the
capital of Sierra Leone, ‘‘but I’m not
sure it will bring closure to the victims.’’
Even so, Mr. Tommy said, the trial
was ‘‘a genuine effort to ensure account-
ability for the crimes in Sierra Leone.’’
In Liberia, supporters of Mr. Taylor
have maintained that he is the victim of
an American witch hunt, but others
lament that his former associates have
prospered and play a role in the new
government.
The tribunal, the Special Court for Si-
erra Leone, which has its main seat in
Freetown, has already sentenced eight
other leading members from different
forces and rebel groups for crimes in Si-
erra Leone. Mr. Taylor, who has main-
Taylor is guilty of aiding
fighters who committed
atrocities in Sierra Leone
ISSOUF SANOGO/AGENCE FRANCE-PRESSE
The trial of Charles G. Taylor, near The Hague, was shown on Thursday at the Special Court for Sierra Leone, whosemain seat is in Freetown, the capital. He was convicted on 11 counts.
BEIJING
BY JONATHAN ANSFIELD
AND IAN JOHNSON
When Hu Jintao, China’s top leader,
picked up the telephone in August to talk
to a senior anti-corruption official visit-
ing Chongqing, special devices detected
that he was being wiretapped— by local
officials in that southwesternmetropolis.
The discovery of that and other
wiretapping led to an official investiga-
tion thathelped toppleChongqing’s char-
ismatic leader,BoXilai, in apolitical cata-
clysm that has yet to reach a conclusion.
Until now, the downfall of Mr. Bo has
been cast largely as a tale of a populist
who pursued his own agenda too ag-
gressively for some top leaders in
Beijing and was brought down by accu-
sations that his wife had arranged the
killing of Neil Heywood, a British con-
sultant, after a business dispute. But the
wiretapping, previously alluded to only
in internal Communist Party accounts
of the scandal, appears to have provided
another compelling reason for party
leaders to turn onMr. Bo.
The story of how the Chinese presi-
dentwasmonitored also shows the level
of mistrust among leaders in the one-
party state. Tomaintain control over so-
ciety, leaders have embraced enhanced
surveillance technology. But some have
turned it on one another — repeating
patterns of intrigue that go back to the
beginnings of Communist rule.
‘‘This society has bred mistrust and
violence,’’ said Roderick MacFarquhar,
a historian of Communist China’s elite-
level machinations over the past half
century. ‘‘Leaders know you have to
watch your back because you never
knowwhowill put a knife in it.’’
Nearly a dozen people with party ties,
speaking anonymously for fear of retri-
bution, confirmed the wiretapping, as
well as a widespread program of bug-
ging across Chongqing. But the party’s
public version ofMr. Bo’s fall omits it.
The official narrative and much for-
eign attention has focused on the more
easily grasped death of Mr. Heywood in
November. When Mr. Bo’s police chief,
Wang Lijun, was stripped of his job and
feared being implicated in Bo family af-
fairs, he fled to the U.S. Consulate in
Chengdu, where he spoke mostly about
Mr. Heywood’s death.
Wiretapping of Hu led
to inquiry and played
a role in official’s ouster
LONDON
BY SARAH LYALL
AND ALAN COWELL
Rupert Murdoch criticized many differ-
ent people on Thursday for many differ-
ent things in a morning of scrappy and
often blunt testimony before a judicial
panel here. But in the most explosive
criticism of all, he suddenly accused two
former employees of presiding over a
‘‘cover-up’’ of phone hacking and other
dubious practices at The News of the
World.
‘‘I do blame one or two people,’’ Mr.
Murdoch said, adding that he did not
want to name them because ‘‘for all I
know they may be arrested,’’ and then
proceeding to make it clear who he
meant, anyway.
One was the now-defunct newspa-
per’s final editor, Colin Myler; and the
otherwas its longtime chief lawyer, Tom
Crone.
‘‘There is no question in my mind
maybe even the editor — but certainly
beyond that, someone — took charge of
a cover-up which we were victim to,’’
Mr. Murdoch said. ‘‘The person I’m
thinkingofwasa friendof the journalists
and a drinking pal and a clever lawyer.’’
Mr. Murdoch’s remarks came on his
second day of testimony before the
Leveson inquiry into the practices of
Britain’s newspapers.NeitherMr.Myler
Fresh face excites Japan city
YUBARI, JAPAN
BY HIROKO TABUCHI
Most young people have already fled
this city of empty streets and shuttered
schools, whose bankrupt local govern-
ment collapsed under the twin burdens
of debt and demographics that are
slowly afflicting the rest of Japan.
Now, Yubari, a former coal-mining
town on Japan’s northernmost main is-
land,Hokkaido, is hoping an unlikely sa-
vior can reverse its long decline: a 31-
year-old rookie mayor who has come to
symbolize the struggle confronting
young Japanese in the world’s most
graying and indebted country.
‘‘Japan will tread the same path
someday,’’ said Naomichi Suzuki, who a
year ago this month became the young-
est mayor of the country’s most rapidly
aging city. ‘‘If we can’t save Yubari,
what will it mean for the rest of Ja-
pan?’’
Indeed, the city’s plight and its at-
tempt to fight back, which has become a
story line in the national media, could
offer a glimpse of Japan’s future.
The country’s overall population fell
by a record quarter-million last year, to
127.8 million, hurt by falling birthrates
and the departure of people for other
countries. By 2060, the Japanese popu-
lation is expected to fall by an additional
one-third, to as few as 87 million, and 40
percent of those remaining will be more
than 65 years old.
Japan’s national debt has not preoc-
cupied the world the way Europe’s has.
But after years of government spending
to shore up the economy, Japanese pub-
lic i.o.u.’s have mushroomed to almost
$12 trillion, more than twice the size of
its economy and the heaviest govern-
ment debt burden in the world. (Its
Treasury is able to keep financing that
debt load by issuing government bonds
because Japan, like the United States, is
still a global investment haven.)
But in Yubari, the demographic and
fiscal demise is on fast-forward. The
city’s population has plunged 90 percent
since its heyday as a coal-mining hub in
the 1950s and ’60s. Currently, fewer than
10,500 people live in a geographic area
approximately the size of New York
City. And of those remaining Yubari res-
idents, nearly half are older than 65.
Unlike the national government,
Yubari has already faced its day of reck-
oning with creditors. Crippled by the
closing of its coalmines as Japanmoved
to petroleum-based fuels and nuclear
Key to lifting hopes
of aging nation may lie
with 31-year-old mayor
KO SASAKI FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES
A quiet street in Yubari, a town as large as NewYork City in area but with fewer than 10,500
people. Its population has fallen 90 percent since its heyday as a coal hub five decades ago.
In spying
on Chinese
leaders, Bo
went too far
Murdoch says
2 ex-employees
staged cover-up
JASON LEE/REUTERS
Beijing was galled that Bo Xilai would
wiretap President Hu Jintao, above.
CHINA, PAGE 6
JAPAN, PAGE 16
MURDOCH, PAGE 4 HAGUE, PAGE 4
Israeli sees Tehran as ‘rational’
The chief of staff of the Israeli Defense
Force has described the Iranian
government as ‘‘rational.’’ PAGE 5
Biden takes aim at Romney
Vice President Joseph R. Biden Jr.
traded jabs and policy points with aides
ofMitt Romney on Thursday. PAGE 6
BUSINESS
Ford’s agility hit by euro crisis
The European unit of FordMotor
presents a vivid example of how
difficult it is tomanage a global car
company these days. It has nimble
productionmethods and high-quality
products, but the economic downturn
has sapped the strength of the
company’smiddle-class buyers. PAGE 14
China courts Eastern Europe
TheChinese primeminister,Wen Jiabao,
said his countrywould offer loansworth
$100 billion a year by 2015 to help
promote development in Central and
EasternEurope, with infrastructure,
high technology and green technology
the target areas for growth. PAGE 14
E.U. banks feel lingering pain
Weak economic growth and a sharp
rise in loan defaults, especially in
Southern Europe, have hit the earnings
of many of the Continent’s largest
financial institutions. Deutsche Bank
and Banco Santander posted declining
profits, but Barclays had a gain. PAGE 14
Dutch make deal FinanceMinister Jan Kees de Jager speaking in TheHague
after the government closed in on a pact to reach E.U. deficit targets. PAGE 4
ROEL ROZENBURG/AGENCE FRANCE-PRESSE
WORLD NEWS
INTERNATIONAL HERALD TRIBUNE
. . . .
politicalwriter, referring to an exclusive
Oxford dining club and the college at
OxfordUniversity that Mr. Cameron at-
tended. ‘‘The almostDarwinian ability
of the old English upper class to adapt
has been demonstrated once again.’’
There is no such continuity on the
continent.Germany’s checkered 20th-
century historywiped out successive
elites: The Kaiserreich fell victim to
theNovember revolution afterWorld
War I. TheNazis annihilated the coun-
try’s Jewish elite and exterminated or
exiled anyone else with a bit of courage
and an independentmind.
In 2012,Germany does not have elite
universities. And the combination of
apprenticeships and employee repres-
entation on corporate boards has
smoothed over differences between
employees and employers in away that
is unthinkable in neighboring France.
Like in Britain, France’s corporate,
political and administrative elite is
groomed in a small number of exclu-
sive schools, the grandes écoles. Ac-
cess to this republican elite is arguably
moremeritocratic; attendance is based
exclusively on entry exams and often
subsidized by state stipends.
But the resulting group of leaders is
smaller,more entangled and no less
disconnected from ordinary people.
Just under half of France’s 40 largest
companies are run by graduates of just
two schools: ENA, the national school
of administration, and the École Poly-
technique, which trains the country’s
top engineers. Together the schools
produce only about 600 graduates a
year. There are fewer than 6,000 ENA
graduates alive today, comparedwith
at least 160,000 Oxford alumni.
‘‘The British elites feel superior be-
cause theywere born superior; the
French elites feel superior because
theywent to ENA,’’ said Dominique
Moïsi, a senior fellow at the French In-
stitute of Foreign Relations, who
spends part of his time in London.
The irony is that, obscure titles and
rituals notwithstanding, in manyways
Britain in 2012 looks more open, liberal
and diverse than continental Europe.
There are black, Muslim and gay
peers in theHouse of Lords (indeed,
there is a blackMuslim gay peer, Lord
Alli). The exclusive department store
Harrods, long a symbol of British iden-
tity, is owned by a Qatari investment
concern. And the prime-time television
news program on the BBC is read by
Hugh Edwardswith aWelsh accent.
Not so long ago, it almost seemed to
be a handicap to hail from the upper
class in Britain. Margaret Thatcher
proved in 1979 that one could become a
conservative primeministerwhile be-
ing not only awoman but a grocer’s
daughterwho had been educated in a
state school.Her successor, JohnMa-
jor, who neverwent to university,
spoke of a ‘‘classless society.’’
As the economy powered ahead and
made everyone feel better off, Tony
Blair famously claimed that ‘‘we are all
middle-class now.’’
‘‘The Thatcher/Blair years de-
stroyed the old class system,’’ Mr.Gar-
ton Ash said, but they also created an
economic systemwhere inequality
flourished, giving rise to a new ‘‘over-
class defined by money inwhich the
old upper class has found its place.’’
For all their differences, Europe’s
elites perhaps share a challenge: not
being deaf to a sense among voters
that there is austerity at the bottom but
not the top.
E-MAIL: pagetwo@iht.com
Class war
returns in
new guises
IN OUR PAGES ✴ 100, 75, 50 YEARS AGO
1912 Russia Ready to Discuss Treaty
ST. PETERSBURG The political speech delivered
to-day [April 26] in theDuma byM. Sazonoff is
attracting attention on account of its clear expos-
ition of Russian foreign policy. TheMinister of
ForeignAffairs stated thatRussia is disposed fa-
vourably to examine the American demands in
regard to a future commercial treaty, but will
take theRussian desiderata into account.Never,
however, will Russia modify its national legisla-
tion relative to the return of Russian emigrants.
M. Sazonoff added that theRusso-FrenchAlli-
ance has by its long duration proved the absence
of any aggressive intention.
Katrin
Bennhold
LETTER FROM EUROPE
LONDON When Prime Minister David
Cameron of Britain (fifth cousin twice-
removed of the queen) and Chancellor
George Osborne (son of a baronet) an-
nounced a tax cut lastmonth for top in-
come earners, the opposition Labour
party mocked them for apparently
thinking Downton Abbeywas a fly-on-
the-wall documentary rather than a
period drama about paternalistic aris-
tocrats and their servile underlings.
When the pair then struggled to recall
the last time they had eaten a pasty— a
popular snack they had just subjected
to a 20 percent sales tax—one tweet
helpfully explained that it was ‘‘like a
boeuf en croûte.’’ Andwhen Francis
Maude, theBritish Cabinet Officeminis-
ter, spoke of ‘‘kitchen suppers,’’ theme-
dia reminded him thatmost voters had
‘‘dinner’’ (middle class) or ‘‘tea’’
(working class) and not necessarily the
option of eating in a dining room.
To an outsiderwho recently moved
to London, it felt like a crash course in
thatmost clichéd, yet real, obsession of
the English: class.
Austerity and rising unemployment
have sharpened the focus on the deep
economic, social and cultural gulf divid-
ing the elites from the vastmajority of
voters in allWestern countries. In the
United States, PresidentBarackObama
has been battling to ensure that the
most wealthy pay at least 30 percent of
their income in taxes. InParis, François
Hollande, the Socialist contending to be-
come France’s next president, has
vowed to tax annual income above ¤1
million, or $1.3million, at 75 percent.
But the notion of classwar is particu-
larly salient in Britain, where income
inequality is greater than in other large
European economies and austerity
more advanced— andwhere the tradi-
tional English upper class has proven
intriguingly adept at preserving its
riches, institutions and influence into
the 21st century.
From the food people eat to everyday
vocabulary and that ultimate giveaway,
the accent, class remains a powerful
identifier on this side of the Channel in a
way that can seemquaint or even al-
mostmedieval to continental Euro-
peans. More than a third of British land
is still in aristocratic hands, according to
a 2010 ownership survey by Country Life
magazine. In the Conservative-Liberal
Democrat coalition cabinet, 15 of the 23
ministerswent to Oxford or Cambridge.
‘‘It is extraordinary that we are once
again governed by the old landed
gentry, theBullingdon Club and
Brasenose tennis club,’’ said Timothy
GartonAsh, the Oxford professor and
1937 Court Rules Against Georgia Law
WASHINGTON In a five-to-four decision, the
United States Supreme Court today [April 26] in-
validated a sixty-six-year-old Georgia law pro-
hibiting insurrection against the state, under
which a Negro Communist had been sentenced
to a prison term of from eighteen to twenty
years. Associate Justice OwenD.Roberts again
joined the four members of the tribunalwho have
been regarded as liberal through their recent de-
cisions onNewDeal social and labor legislation.
Reading themajority opinion, JusticeRoberts
said: ‘‘The lawviolates the guarantee of liberty
embodied in the FourteenthAmendment.’’
1962 Ranger-4 Hits Far Side of Moon
GOLDSTONE , CALIFORNIA TheUnited States
scored amajor advance in space today [April 26]
when the crippled spacecraftRanger-4 crash-
landed on the far side of themoon. It wasAmer-
ica’s first success in seven attempts to land a
space shot on themoon, and virtually duplicated
the feat of Russia’s Lunik